America’s Pie at the Beach

Not a fan. The pizza was taste like card board. Definitely not even close to the best in town. I will stick with the big 3 that have been here for years.

What a wonderful place to get great, interesting pizza! Oh sure, you can get a huge slice of cheese for $ 2.99 (a slice is ¹⁄₆ of an extra large pie!) but go the extra dollar for some of their crazy combo slices. I am a fan of «Holiday White.» Spinach broccoli and ricotta – so good. Just walk in, slices are all on display and pick out what looks good. Having tried maybe 10 different kinds, none disappoint. They have much other good stuff on the menu, great soups and salads. But here is the best part: the owners are on site, they say they will make any pizza for you that you want, and they always try so hard to please. And it works. We love, love this place!

Terrible food. Great service. Not surprising given its location.

I must say that it is refreshing these days to go anywhere and be recieved with smiling friendly staff. That is exactly what you will get here. The service is prompt and the pizza is good. Its not the best pizza on the planet but it walks all over most of the other joints around. Slices are huge. Try it. You wont regret it.

We were very unhappy with our pizza. Modest ingredients, hard crust. We won’t return.

Great casual pizza joint! Don’t let the off-​the-​Boardwalk location fool you: this is the best pizza in town. With a full menu of tasty items including hot dogs, nachos, tacos, pizzas, salads and homemade soups, this joint is a great addition to Rehoboth. Well priced and super casual (counter seating only) with Americana décor and knowledgeable and friendly staff, the food was delicious. Mike (owner) was engaged in everything from order taking to pizza preparation and we enjoyed chatting with him.

I was staying in the area for a few days and wanted a simple pizza? I made a phone call to Americas Pie and it was the best call I made ! I ordered a salad and traditional pie. I went to pick it up and was told the pizza may be a bit over cooked, so they were making me another which would take about 15 minutes.
I had no problem waiting at all ! The manager and staff gave me garlic knots, & bread pudding for my inconvenience of waiting only 15 minutes !! Not only that, the manager walked my pie to my car and with the pie which they felt was over cooked !!! I had 2 pies !! This is a well rounded business with exceptional staff ! The pizza, salad, garlic knots were delicious! I am from the NY area and pizza we know and so does American Pie ! Great pizza ! When I return to the area soon I will make it my first stop to eat and say hello !!
Do yourself a favor, want a great pie with wonderful people, make a visit.
Thank you Americas Pie ! Great job !!

Another contender in the beach pizza market (Nicola’s, Grotto, Dough Roller, Louie’s). Staff was helpful and friendly. A nice choice of pizza and toppings by the the slice, or whole pie. Their specials are good value. They also have a small menu of soups and sandwiches. The only complaint is seating, or lack thereof. You have to sit on stools facing the wall, as there are no tables. Great food though, and you can also take a slice outside to eat it on the boardwalk.

I’m not one to hand out 5-​stars easily, but I’d be hard pressed to NOT give America’s Pie all five. My wife and I stopped in here on a whim this weekend after the Nor’easter blew through, and we were very pleased with our visit. A very friendly staff paired with a menu full of choices started the visit on the right foot. We both got pizza, and we were impressed by the food. The pizza had a thin crust that was cooked just right, and there wasn’t an overabundance of pizza sauce. The taste was spot-​on in our book. She had a slice of plain cheese pizza, while I had a slice each of the pineapple & ham and the pineapple and bacon. These were some of the biggest, juiciest pieces of pineapple I’ve had on a pie, and I enjoyed every bite. Yes, the seating is limited to bar-​style seating along the walls. But the place is pretty small, so there’s not much else they could do in there. Minor annoyance for those looking for a more «traditional table» setting perhaps. But overall, we had an excellent lunch, and we’ll certainly be back.

I had heard good things about the pizza here so I decided to give it a shot. Drove on the snow to pick up a pizza and I’m not sorry at all! The menu is HUGE; with a ton of great sounding salads, sandwiches and of course pizza. I decided to go simple and try the White Pizza. It is now my favorite local pizza spot (sorry Mr Ps) The crust was done, thin and tasty. It isn’t crumbly, but it has none of the undercooked doughy feel so many places seem to have. TONS of garlic (in the best way) and it is seasoned perfectly. The cheese was creamy and sharp at the same time. Excited to try the rest of the menu. As a bonus the place is really cute and super clean. I can imagine that the staff was looking to go home, but they were super nice and very accommodating. They are doing everything right so head on in and enjoy!

Awesome selection! Really wanna try the street corns. Would love to see more vegetarian options. Pleased to know they delivery to Lewes! Will be back soon and often.

Pizza pretty good per my wife… I had the hummus platter since I didn’t want to make us late for the movies by getting a pie without cheese (which the chef said he could do no problem!). Hummus was just ok and kinda pricey at 9.95. Wife’s 2 slices were served up hot and dripped a bit of grease but overall a thumbs-​up. Looks like they have local delivery. Customer service rates a 4 with everyone smiling and asking for feedback. Downside is the bright lights! Jeesh, you could perform brain surgery in there. Reminds me of Tom Hanks at work in Joe vs. the Volcano !
Enjoy.

America’s Pie provided a GREAT holiday party for our group! Super food, great delivery service and the FREE Monday pizza was a nice added touch. Everyone loved their food– freshly made, nicely organized and truly delicious. Thanks to the gang at America’s Pie.

Crab chili? Brisket on pizza? This place is adventurous! Bravo!
The place is kinda a cross between a NYC pizzeria, and an all American diner in its décor. Then mix in a really clever menu that you just won’t find at other RB pizzerias… Ding! We have a winner!
The one dig? Wall counter type eat in only– no tables. It’s fine if you’re buying ‘a slice of pie’, but if you get a whole one, take some time to figure out if it’ll sit on the counter, because their Large pizzas are LARGE!

What a great new pizza option at the beach! Not only was the pizza delicious, the slices were huge. We are super picky about pizza and this totally fit the bill. The service was also the friendliest I have received in awhile. Can’t wait to go back and try some other options.

Stopped by here tonight as we wanted something quick and easy and boy am I glad we did!
First, the staff here was exceptional friendly. They explained all the different slices available and offered to make fresh pies if we wanted a slice they didn’t have. They also offered tasting of their soup, which we ultimately declined but were extremely good!
My partner and I both had a slice of the James Dean — BBQ Chicken, Scallion, Red Onions, Pepper Jack, Mozzarella and topped with Chipotle Ranch. It was beyond amazing — everything a pizza should be. Hot, gooey, perfect foldable crust, the right amount of toppings… yum. We also shared an order of the garlic knots and OMG… best garlic knots ever. Warm, chewy and enough garlic to knock a vampire out a mile away.
If you are in Rehoboth, I highly recommend you stop by and give this place a chance!

Just got my BBQ chicken Hawaiian pizza delivered to my home and it’s simply fantastic!!! Many have been saying great things so I had to give it a go and I’m BETTER OFF FOR IT!!! Haha
Great pizza and very friendly service! Jen was a pleasure to order from and accommodated my every request! Mangia!

Good pizza is in short supply at the Delaware shore. America’s Pie is off to a good start. My first pie was a Margherita with pepperoni and green pepper added. The crust on America’s pizza is close to excellent, as is the sauce and fresh mozzarella. However, the pie maker seemed to skimp on the meat and cheese. My extra large pie came to $ 24, on the high side, so the portions should be generous. Also, the cheese was not spread evenly over the pie, but in clumps. I will give them another try at some point. It’s good to have them in town — it may improve the pizza market.

Simple! Delicious. Awesome pies and dogs with fresh ingredients. The chili is home made as is the crab cream cheese is awesome on the Crab Rangoon Dog. Pizza crust was thin and full of taste! Very little seating but don’t let that deter you. If you must, get it to go! Very glad we tried it here and didn’t let the carry out style steer us away.

This is by far the best pizza I’ve had at either the MD or DE shore. Tastes just like the pizza I’m used to from PA and NJ. Just FYI, the hot peppers are HOT. Unlike most pizza places that fill out their menu with cheesesteaks, hoagies, and pasta, America’s has tacos, hot dogs, gourmet corn, sliders, and all kinds of other cool stuff that I hope to try next time I’m in Rehoboth.
Also the staff couldn’t have been more friendly.
Highly recommend this place. They’re new and so don’t have a lot of ratings yet, but don’t hold that against them, this is WAY better than all the other pizza places in Rehoboth.