Jimmy John’s

Worst Jimmy John’s ever!
I have eaten at Jimmy John’s all over the country, mainly in the Midwest and West coast and usually love their sandwiches. I have tried this location more than once and have always been let down. This location just somehow always disappoints. The staff is friendly, but the food is terrible. I don’t know if this store uses a different brand of cold cuts or cuts them too thick, but something about the sandwiches just never tastes good. If I want a chain sandwich, I would rather go Jersey Mike’s and get a far superior sub. Although, nothing really replaces a local deli.

The Roseland Jimmy John’s off of Eisenhower Parkway is very good. This was the first Jimmy John’s that I ever went to before and it left a good impression with me. Since then, I still haven’t had a bad experience in there yet.
The staff are friendly and the sandwiches are made well. Plus, parking is never an issue since there is a private lot for customers in the shopping plaza. It’s a good option if you are in the area and are in the mood for a sub. I go for the #3 Totally Tuna or #6 The Veggie (with hot peppers).

Great service. The people who work there are so friendly and professional. Their sub are to die for and are freaky fast. Love this place They even do catering

My favorite place to either grab a quick bite or get delivered. Love their sandwiches (especially the hot peppers on top and the bread) and their super fast service.

I ate there yesterday and had the # 10. Roast Beef with lettuce, tomato, provolone and mayo. Awesome! RB was tender, pink in middle, bun was fresh — everything about it was top notch. $ 7 and the owner, Andrew was there as well. Sandwich was made before my eyes and was done in seconds! Highly recommend

When i opened the paper wrapped around my sandwich today I thought of the old fashioned vending machines with sandwiches in the door. Sandwich squished all together, skimpy tomatoes the size of quarters, skimped on the lettuce. Didn’t even ask me if i wanted any other items on my #2 roast beef sub, just slapped and wrapped. Even Subway asks and they are thee worst sandwiches! If you eat inside there are no garbage cans to be found. You have to ask for napkins, needless to say i wont be visiting this *cough* «sandwich» shop in my own town again.

Sandwiches are ok. First time here .
Could have used a little more turkey on my sandwich. Didn’t want mayo the cashier suggested other items to add to my sandwich such as Dijon mustard seasonings etc. Which I thought as nice .
Added chips and soda $ 9. Could have gone to subway and got a combo for less .
Bread was fresh eh in is why they got four stars and the cashiers suggestions.

Great prices, super friendly staff. Try any sandwich as a unwich (low carb) my favorite is #12 add bacon.

Very very disappointed. 3 total pieces of meat. Little or no lettuce on my Vito #5. My had a turkey sub. 1 pieces of turkey. The sub from parsippany location was very good. If your in the mood for a Jimmy John’s go there!

Consistently good sandwiches and service. Prices are very reasonable for a great quality sub. Always come in for lunch when I want a sandwich!

Where’s the meat!!! The amount of meat they put in the sub is a travesty. I love your bread, but other than that, I basically was eating a veggie sub. This could have been a mistake, but I called them and they said its by portion. So, it wasn’t a mistake — this is in fact the amount of meat they put. :-(

Reasonably priced sandwiches that tastes good. Perfect for lunch. They are quick.
Staff has been good the three times I have been there and place is neat and clean.
I have had tuna all three times and sandwich was made well with fresh ingredients.

Best place to grab a quick lunch during the work week in the Roseland area! My go-​to is the Italian Nigh Club. The staff is very welcoming and the service is second to none. The food is always fresh and I’ve never left there wanting more or feeling like I didn’t get the most for my money. Wouldn’t go anywhere else for a sandwich/​sub!

Had samples… turkey, ham and cheese (didn’t try that one), and avocado. The samples were very generous in size and I believe it is worth making a trip to this spot, which took over the old Muscle Maker Grill.

What an awesome Jimmy Johns! As someone who loved this chain in the Midwest, was psyched to see it open in NJ! The bread is just perfect, fresh and tasty. The meats are real, sliced daily and not pulled out of a bag like at other chains. Plus this store looked great, had friendly staff and as usual was freaky fast. Gotta love the JJs NJ!

This is a sandwich chain that’s got a big presence in the Midwest. Their sandwiches are good, quality is a notch better than Subway. Bread is fresh, so is the produce and meats. The selection is not as varied as Quiznos. They do a good business at lunch but are somewhat disorganized as they call out your selection rather than give you a receipt with an order number as they do at most fast food restaurants.
It’s 3.5 stars but I went the low route because the lack of disorganization is somewhat annoying.

My first Jimmy Johns was in Wisconsin and it was great. I was thrilled to see a Jimmy Johns open up near me. So of course, I had to try it and guess what: amazing! SO good. SO fresh. SO right. It hits the spot whether it’s for lunch or dinner! And the staff has been great at making sure my two small girls even get something they love. 5 stars and two thumbs up!

One thing I love about jimmy johns is it’s price, quality of ingredients and consistency. Whether I’m in MN, NC or NJ, the food and spritely service is always the same, very good! So glad they opened one in Roseland!
Fave sandwiches include: #12.Beach club, #Turkey Tom, #14 bootlegger and new fave #17 the ultimate porker.
They also have great chips in low fat, BBQ and jalapeño!

Long time user of JJ from college in Texas. That said, I had high expectations.
The good: fresh bread, quality meats and crisp veggies.
The bad: having to repeat your order to the same kid 4x and they still jack it up beyond belief. Have been 4 times now and only once the order was correct.
I will continue to tell friends JJ is better than Jersey Mikes, but maybe mgmt should spend a little more time with the employees that are building the sandwiches.

I was a long time patron of Jimmy John’s while attending Syracuse. It was my absolute favorite and was greatly missed when I moved back home. Not only are the sandwiches fantastic, but I was able to continue to be a loyal customer when I transitioned to low-​carb and started getting «Unwiches» (lettuce wrapped sandwiches). Any sandwich can be done as an Unwich. The flavors in everything are great and I’ve pretty much tried the whole menu. The prices are also super reasonable for the amount of food that you get.
Now on to the new Roseland location; I was so excited when I saw the sign for JJ’s opening soon and waited impatiently for the grand opening. Just devoured my first Unwich from this new spot and can confirm that they did not disappoint. It was fantastic! They are off to a really great start. The inside was really nicely renovated and clean. Even though the staff was new, they were determined, efficient, and polite. I should reiterate, my food was delicious and I will definitely be going back as well as ordering delivery from them on a regular basis. I’m glad that I got to be their first reviewer and wish them great success!