Goodfellas Pizza

Best pizza in south lake Tahoe! The guy that always works there is nice keeps the place clean and friendly! Thank you for a great experience every time:)

The pizza is OK, nothing to race about, but they have a decent product and excellent customer service. After being treated like horse shit at two Blue Dog Pizza locations we finally ordered with godfellows and received a prompt, accurate, and friendly delivery. Way to beast your competition into the ground! Never will I patronize Blue Dog Pizza again, good customer service goes a long long way!

So glad I decided to stop by Goodfellas! The pizza was great! Perfect amount of sauce and real cheesy. I bought a small two-​topping pizza with small soda for $ 16. The small pizza is enough to feed 3 people. I received a free ½ order of pizza chips (thin sliced pizza) for checking in on Unilocal.I’m not giving 5 stars because the wait was ridiculous. I stood in line for 30 mins to order the pizza, then waited another 30 to get the food. There was only two people working, so I give them credit for handling the customers well.

We took our 3 kids here last night. The pizza was good, salad bar was nice and it was a perfect relaxed atmosphere after skiing all day! We recommend! It cost us the same for a dinner for five as it did for two drinks up on Heavenly!

Called in to order delivery and girl answered the phone and she sounded incompetent. She took my order in which I had to repeat myself over and over again for her to get the order right. Then when I told her the address to deliver she didn’t even get that right. Told her I was going to pay with my debit card and she said that should be fine then hangs up. I assume that I would pay with my card when the delivery guy comes. She said it would take an hour. Two hours pass and still no deliver guy. I called this place again and asked when was my food going to be delivered and the guy that answered the phone said the guy should be there any minute. I asked why was it taking so long and he said they got really busy. Really? Busy? No call letting me know the food would be late? Terrible communication! Then I wait another 45 mins and finally my food was delivered. It was cold and looked like they took the good out of the garbage and put it in a box. I wish I could have took a picture of it. The worst chicken parmasean I’ve ever had. I can’t believe they serve that to people. On top of that I told the delivery guy I am paying with card and he said I had to call in to pay that. If the girl gave me the correct info in the beginning I wouldn’t have had to call them again.
The delivery guy was not very friendly and he was late. He didn’t even apologize for being two and half hours late. Then when I call to pay for the cold disgusting food the guy took my card number down and said the total today would be 60 bucks I said no all I ordered was pasta and he said oh oops someone else ordered food from that same location. Wow! Terrible food and bad communication. This experience really set me off. If I could give them negative stars I would.

They served me breadsticks with straight up MOLD on them. MOLD. Big old green fuzzy spots. I asked for my money back and left. Dude was a jerk and their food was literally rotten. I tried one chicken wing before I saw the nasty breadsticks; they were undercooked and gummy. Expired, old, gross, and nasty food.

Went to Lake Tahoe and wanted to try a pizza place this time, well this place was recommend on Unilocal,and we show up around noon. It says on Unilocal at 11 AM they open, well it’s 12 and not open yet? I guess. You should probably change that…

The crusts were very good. They have a sweet yeasty flavor that means made fresh. The pepperoni was spicy and pesto was bomb. Pitchers of beer are reasonably priced. One of the better pies in stahoe.

Great pizza at affordable price. The service was average and the setting was good. I would do it again just because of the pizza and cheese sticks.

Goodfella’s is the best pizza in town great price great food and drinks and the atmosphere is very comfortable!

$ 15 minimum delivery. Order was delivered in the time frame given which is great for a snowy night. Food was hot when it arrived. The chicken wings were a little small and were by no means «hot» but we’re moist and baked well. The calzone had a ton of cheese and a fair amount of the 2 toppings I ordered. Used the Unilocal for free half order of chips. Might have been the best part. I would definitely recommend trying this place.

the pizza was good. no complaints there. their service was a bit slow; our order wasn’t ready by the estimated time and had to wait a little, so our ice cream that we had bought nearby melted. overall, i think i’d go back there again.

2 stars for the check-​in offer and that item being tasty. Although the guy there seemed to dislike the fact I was cashing it in… Honestly the free item was larger than the pizzas and tasted better too.

Delicious!!! On a whim we picked a pizza parlor from Unilocal and found this gem! Great customer service and fabulous pizza. On the pricier side, but probably not for Tahoe. Yes, we will definitely be getting pizza from here again! Had the veggie and the white out. Awesome!!! Can’t wait to try another kind!

First time here. Great atmosphere and customer service. The pizza arrived piping hot. Good portion size. Thanks for the free pesto chips for Check In deal. It’s would have been better if they serve free soda refills like other pizza joints. Overall good experience.

Goodfellas is a good pizza option if you’re near the South Lake Tahoe marina. For about $ 24 we were able to get a large pizza which is huuge and more than enough to share with a family of four. They allow ordering half and half so we tried the Veggie delight and the Garden Delight. Also take advantage of that check in offer for a free ½ order of pizza chips. Their pizza chips are essentially pizza but on thin crust – I’d suggest going with the pesto flavor, delish!
But on to the pizza: The pizza has been hit or miss for me. The first time I tried their veggie delight pizza, I loved it and the second time the crust had no salt so it tasted really bland. BUT it does come with a ton of veggies so I have to give them props for not skimping on toppings. The garden delight pizza has avocado on it which was… interesting. I love avocado so I thought this could be a good combination but it turns out that avos don’t really work with pizza. Also some of the avocado on our pizza had started turning black so that was a bummer too.
Overall, a good bang for your buck to feed a large group.

Grumpy staffing, horrible worst wings ever. Pizza is gross will never them again. Owner is not a present person

First off, If you are doing take out add a star and a half. The pizza is actually tasty. Good crust, zesty sauce and quality cheese and toppings. Good to-​go pizza place.
But if you stay…
they need to step up their game… Ordered a couple draft beers and got half beer half foam. They offered to top it off but you still have to deal with the same issue.
7.99 all you can eat salad bar, don’t bother you won’t want to take more than 1 trip. Fake bacon bits, salad dressing that’s starting to separate, and white ice berg lettuce with very little green. The tomatoes looked like they’d been assaulted. Some improvements could definitely be made in this area.
And it was 85 degrees inside… A little warm for a June evening in Tahoe.
And then there’s the duct tape holding the curtains in place. I’m a fan of duct tape, just doesn’t give me a lot confidence in the restaurant.

The pizza was ok, we ordered half hawaiian and half cheese for our little one. For me the crust was under done and chewy. I don’t think I’d dine in again, it has a really small dining room which would be fine — if it were clean. I really wanted to like it, especially because of the name Goodfellas!

I used to order sandwiches and pesto chips for delivery at least once a week for a few months a year ago, I guess quality has gone down in the time I hadn’t ordered there. I ordered a usual oven baked salami and cheese sandwich with a half order of pesto chips. The pesto chips were okay but the sandwich was hella burnt. Now I’m a cook so I can deal with a slight char but it was straight black on both ends of the sandwich and was only served because it was a delivery order. If this was ordered in house it would have been unacceptable. The manager refunded the money for the sandwich which I appreciated but all of this could have been avoided with simple quality control.