Pie Five Pizza Co

Pretty good. It’s plain but good, I’ve come back to it a couple of times. Clean and good quality.

First time eating here, Pizza was descent at best. Same concept as &pizza, but doesn’t hold a flame to &pizza. Customer service was top notch and I wished the pizza was as good as the service. No real desire to go back for the same reason others listed, as better options are close by.

Best pizza in town!
My favorite place to eat pizza!
You all need to try the «five star» with everything!

Eh not great but not horrible. I wouldn’t go back seeing as there is better pizza places in the area.

I tried this place out yesterday because we were in the mood for a pizza and needed something fast. Customer service was wonderful and we both got delicious pizza. I like that they offer a variety of crusts and toppings. It was very clean and spacious. We will definitely be back!

I tried this place a few months ago but forgot to review it. I had a grand opening «free pie» coupon but that is in no way swaying my rating. I didn’t know what to expect but the place is sort of like a chipotle-​style place for pizza. You go to the counter and pick your crust style, your cheeses, toppings (if I recall it’s unlimited toppings). They make it right there and put into mega-​hot oven and done within a few minutes. I kept it basic with pepperoni and onion and thin crust and it tasted very good. Better than I expected for «fast food» pizza. I also got a side salad which was good (it came in a bowl made of pizza crust).
This place would be great for a fast lunch, carry out or family evening dinner. If you’re looking for date night or beer/​wine with your dinner it may not be the right place as I don’t think they offer that.

Its not my favorite pizza place but I thought I’d give them a try since we had coupons. The pizzas are on the small side so the average person might be able to finish one on their own. You pick your own toppings or they also have pizza’s you can choose from if you’re not feeling creative. We got the BBQ chicken and I don’t remember the name of the other one but it had cheese, chicken, spinach, garlic, olive oil, and sun-​dried tomatoes. It was pretty good and I like the concept. I also liked the fact that you could get whole grain crust. I’d go again since its not too far.

I have ate here about 2 – 3 times as I live close by and I really enjoy their pizzas. I’ve gotten the Tuscan and carbonara and liked both of them. The thin crust is nice and not too crunchy. It’s cheap and the chocolate chip cookie pie is alright as well. It’s a better alternative if you’re looking for a pizza night than domino’s, Papa Johns or Pizza Hut.

Giving it a high review because the staff is always enthusiastic and very nice! The pizza tastes like any other pizza place, so I wasn’t too «wow’d». The idea of making your own pizza the way you want it is a nice concept, though. Came here because they offered coupons… would come back if we had some more coupons haha

I called to order a pizza for carryout and was told I can not order over the phone since they are ready so quickly. I live less than 5 minutes away and have no interest in waiting or ever checking out this establishment. There are tons of pizza places in the area to order from. Pie Five will be removed permanently from my list.

The staff was super helpful and friendly! The pizza was pretty good, especially for a 6 min pizza. Unlimited toppings and sauces, so that was pretty sweet. I’ll definitely be back!

I guess if you go on a limited budget and are tired of Subway or Chipoltle, the place is ok. But to compare it to other pizza places that serve a home made pie with wood burning ovens or New York slices than they fall a bit short. But I see the attraction. Its relatively quick and the pizzas do not taste bad, but they don’t say I got to get another one anytime soon either.

The Chipotle of pizza, maybe subway is a better comparison with the way they limit amount of toppings. The pizza is good but not amazing, and the salads are unique but to be honest the pizza could be cooked to be warmer, but I get thin crust so maybe that’s too blame.
Overall unique experience and fun with friends but the food isn’t anything amazing.

Wife and I had a «Buy one/​Get one» coupon so we went there Friday evening for the first time. Was impressed with the choices, how fast the pizza took to bake, and impressed with the taste. Might be my new «go to» fast food place when I just don’t want a burger. The staff was VERY friendly and responsive!
Recommend giving it a try!

OKay, much better.
I went back. Had a coupon. Got the same thing as before, but did not get the spicy sauce, or the magic dust. No olive taste this time.
I am again impressed with how fast the pizza is prepared.

PFP is a welcome addition to the Sterling food option scene. Why’s that? Well it basically takes the &pizza concept and makes it accessible to the suburbs.
The inside is spacious, very pizza, parlor-​y, and the staff is friendly and accommodating.
There is one set price for all pizzas ($ 7.99 + tax), and you can create something totally your own from scratch or tweak pre-​conceived topping combos. It’s really a great model to get a pizza exactly the way you want it. I had a BOGO voucher, so I opted to get the Five Star and Tuscan Chicken pizzas.
The Five Star is as close as you can get to your classic Everything — it’s got the usual suspects of peppers, sausage, pepperoni, olives, onion, red sauce, etc. The crust is the usual density (which I prefer on almost all my pizzas in general), though as another reviewer pointed out, you can tell that it’s pre-​made and defrosted at the restaurant (the almost-​too-​smooth and slightly sweet consistency give it away). However, despite this, the flavor is good.
The Tuscan Chicken pizza comes on the «Artisan» crust, which is a thinner crust — it’s NOT a flatbread, which is a good thing. Flavor combo on this was actually quite nice as well. I also asked to pop on some banana peppers on it to give it a bit more vinegary tang than it would have had without. Not very Tuscan, but that’s the beauty of build-​you-​own-​pizza shops.
Overall, you know what you’re getting into, and hey, PFP does a great job at what they do. I was hoping for a slightly more enlightening pizza experience, but for the price and convenience, you can’t really beat it in the area. If you want a pizza exactly your way and quick, PFP should be on your list.

Probably would have been a 3-​star review, but the service was great!
So 3.5 stars.
They have a meal deal which consists of your own personal pizza (any syle, any crust), a side salad OR dessert, and a soda. Not bad for around $ 10.
FOOD:
===========================
The personal pizza was okay. I tried to personalize my «Farmer’s Market» choice by adding meats to it (I am a carnivore, I need more veggies probably). The person making my pizza gladly added the sausage and pepperoni to my pizza. YAY (I wish I tried more meats since their pizzas are unlimited toppings though…)!
I got the traditional crust, which was pretty tasteless, to be honest. My boyfriend’s thin crust pizza was a little better, but oily. I enjoyed the cute little pizza crust bowl for the side salad, but just for viewing purposes. It was bland; like a very crisp, unsweetened pie crust.
The dessert was actually the highlight of my meal. Turtle brownie slice with caramel drizzle. YUM, dessert pizza to end a pizza-​based meal is always a winner for lunch.
SUMMARY:
===========================
To sum it up, food is just OK. I could tell the two women working were trying (and succeeded) to give us good customer service. They checked up on us while eating, even. 2 thumbs up for service, 1 thumb for food!

Good pizza and salads. I like the choices. We ordered the kid’s cheese, farmer’s market and 5 star pizzas and Greek and Italian salads. The cashier and pizza makers are nice. You can tell though they are still working through the kinks. It took them a bit to get organized and get the pizzas and salad together but it turned out well.
My main complaint is the Arctic blast you get every time someone walks in/​out the door. Today is 25 degrees and you definitely feel it.
I would also recommend they carry milk or juice for the little ones.
We will return but only after the weather warms up a bit.

Spotted a just opened sign in front of this place while looking for somewhere to eat with a friend and thought we’d give it a try. This place is basically the Chipotle of pizza: you go down a line of ingredients and choose how to customize your pizza, it’s really fast (hence the name Pie Five) and the place is clean and spacious. There are also pre-​made options if you don’t want to make your own pizza. I chose the BBQ Chicken Pizza, and since I was hungry also decided to «bundle it» with a drink and dessert, which totaled to just over $ 11. The pizza was really good, I enjoyed the cilantro on top in particular. I think if I ever came back I’d bundle with the salad instead since it comes in a cute little toasted pita bowl and the dessert was just okay. They have a rewards program too which is nice if you’re a big fan of pizza and plan to come a lot.

Are you tired of carrying those long boxes, and eating that long pizza?
Then you’ve came to the right place. This place is a pizza place, but they specialize in personal pizzas. The pizzas only take 5 minutes to cook, hence the name Pie Five. Their menu has great options to choose from, but there is even a build your own pizza!
I came in here, and everything was set up conveniently. The employees were all helpful and courteous. I was unsure of what to put on my Pizza, but decided I want to be creative, so i went with the BBQ sauce, and chicken. After 5 minutes my pizza was done. I did a bundle, and it was very inexpensive!
After first bite, I was in delight. Everything from the pizza to the crust was very yummy. The only problem I had was that it was so good, I had to purchase another pizza!
I had no problems with the helpful employees. This place was very clean too, even the bathrooms were clean as well.
I would highly recommend this place to friends, family, and strangers.
I will def. be back!