Times Square Pizza & Bagels

Heard about this place from a friend and when down tasting wines stopped by for some garlic knots and meat lovers pizza. OUTSTANDING …perfect ny style pizza and the knots were delicious.

The best pizza here in the Temecula area hands down! I’ve never been a fan of pizza by the slice, but for some reason their buffalo chicken pizza by the slice is sooo good. It has such a buttery taste to every bite. Their NY White pizza is absolutely amazing. The ricotta gives it such a richness that’s second to none. Their buffalo wings are baked, not fried which I’m a fan of. Eat here you won’t regret it

Ordered from Grub Hub, the order came earlier than expected so timing was wonderful! The breakfast bagel was AMAZING! As was the pizza and salad! Definitely will be ordering frequently from here.

The pizza, garlic knots and wings are all delicious! Everyone working there is so nice too. I think this is the best pizza place in Temecula by far!

This is one of the few places that delivers to De Luz. They have gluten free pizza dough. They skimp a little on the toppings, so make sure you add another topping to compensate. I have ordered from them about a dozen times. They have messed up the order 3 of those times (sending the wrong salad, croutons in the salad when I requested none (gluten intolerant and can’t even eat something that has touched gluten or I spend the night throwing up) and left off a topping I paid for. I did not complain to them about the missing topping. I did call them back the times they messed up the salad. The credited me the salads for free on my next visit. I appreciated that
The are friendly and I appreciate the delivery. I will continue using them.

Time Square pizza is a very good place to stop in for a slice. I have eaten here twice and both times service and pizza far above the competition. The establishment is clean cozy. I do wish they replace the wall booth style couch, they sit too high.

Wow. The best pizza I ever had in my life. Excellent customer service. Very nice and clean with open view of kitchen. You know that they are clean. I would highly recommend it. They are number one and there is a reason for it.

Best pizza I’ve had in a very long time! And the wings were so good! We will definitely go back! Hopefully soon! The owner (I’m assuming) was also very nice!

Got 2 pizzas to go and some chicken wings. Drove straight home so my family could enjoy fresh hot food for dinner. This was among my bookmarked restaurants for a long time. I’m glad we finally got to try their food.
The pizzas are New York style and so delicious. I think this is my new favorite pizza place close to home. The service was excellent as well.

Ordered Chicken Caesar Salad and Hot Wings. I got raw chicken. I have pictures. They refused to refund me. Never. Ever. Ever again.

Hello Guys
Just wanted to to wish you guys the very best New Year.
Lots of health and happiness for years to come.
Keep on making the VERY BEST PIZZA AS YPU ALWAYS DO.
If anyone else is reading this, it does not pay to go anywhere else.
If you are looking for Real thin crust pizza this is the place.
All my best to all you Pizza lovers out there.

Ordered the family deal, large pizza, large salad, garlic knots and 2 liter soda for $ 24.99. Pizza was very delicious, New York style. Garlic knots and salad were perfect as well. Found this place on Unilocal and was glad I did.

The pizza is great here and reasonably priced. For a 17″ half pepperoni and half pepperoni, mushroom and sausage was only $ 22. We dined in and the place is rather small, not a large dining area but they do have two tv’s which were showing football. Since we are from out of town we may not be able to come again. But they do deliver and I would recommend them to all who live in the area.

I’ve ordered delivery a few times from this location. Each time, I’ve been very pleased with my order.
Seriously good pizza! Lots of good flavor and perfect crust, sauce, and cheese ratio. Pizza lovers know just how important this is…
Prompt delivery. All of the delivery staff have been so nice and helpful. Deliveries have always occurred within the time frame they have provided.

I still highly recommend this place because the food is awesome. I wanted to reach out to the restaurant in writing (not on Unilocal) but since there is no email contact on the restaurant’s Facebook page, I am updating my review instead.
So, first, your food is great. No downgrade on quality. Second, your staff is really nice. The person that took my order the phone was super helpful and the person that made the delivery was really nice and even helped me with my puppy that decided to make a break for it. Your customer service is fantastic. I would give you 10 stars on customer service if that was an option.
I have two suggestions for you.
#1 — I love that when I called in, you were able to pull up my last order. It (pleasantly) caught me off guard and it made me forget to ask about crust. I really wanted a thin crust pizza and so if you could confirm crust as well as toppings that would be amazing. But I really appreciate you already knowing what we like and I want to commend you for doing that. Thank you.
#2 — I asked if I could have extra sausage if I paid for it. Of course the person answering the phone said yes. That didn’t happen. This is hardly a thing to complain about because you did a 99% perfect job but getting that part right would have been appropriate. I am sure that your pizza prep folks are moving really fast but if a customer requests to *PAY FOR* additional toppings, there should be an operating procedure in place for highlighting that request.
That’s it. We will absolutely order again because you are great and you are our go-​to pizza joint in The Mec :~)

Wow!!!
Made me nostalgic for New York! The best pizza I’ve had outside of New York! Bar none!
Residents of Temecula and surrounding areas, if you haven’t tried it, you are missing one of the best foods available in your area.

I’m visiting from out-​of-​town and my family usually frequents Stadium Pizza Friday nights. I’m not a huge fan: too loud and too crowded. I’m also not too big on pizza, unless it’s NY style. And now, since I have to eat gluten-​free, I needed to find a place to suit my needs.
Times Square fit my needs. Sure, the gluten-​free pizza was only 10″, and I didn’t get big, foldable slices with drippy cheese and a sprinkle of oregano, but the toppings were fantastic. The sausage was flavorful and their sauce was very nice.
Everyone working there was great and the manager (?) made my pizza himself. He explained the process to me, to avoid cross-​contamination. They unwrap the crust in the walk-​in, and top it in there as well, using fresh ingredients. It’s then placed in a different oven.
I really enjoyed my pizza and the service. I would definitely come back. I saw a customer with a salad and would like to try one of those too.
My uncle, who doesn’t like change, grumbled a bunch, but did like his artichoke pizza. He said it was good, but it was «different» from the one he gets at Stadium. I thought it was a work of art! He did complain that it was too bright inside. I guess there are two sets of lights– in-​ceiling lights and pendant lighting. Maybe if they could figure out a way to shut off half (or all) the in-​ceiling lights? I don’t know … Just relaying the message. Haha. Oh! One more– dad didn’t like that there was no Bud Light (yeah, no worries, I already made fun of his «fine» taste in beer). So he «suffered» through the extra calories in Blue Moon. Bah.
All in all, I really enjoyed it! I wish we had won over the old timers, but watcha goin’ do aboutit?

Bagel review only!
Went in for a bagel as I have heard great things! First off I paid $ 5.93 for one bagel and an OJ! Highway robbery plain and simple! That means each were close to $ 3!
I ordered an everything bagel which I asked to be toasted, so he put it in the pizza oven. Not the same thing! It got warm, but not actually toasted! Bummer! Cream cheese schmear was decent but portioned by an ice cream scooper.
The bagel itself was good but blah! The inside was fairly doughy and not well done like it should be!
The OJ wasn’t fresh it was out of a container and I could tell!
I’m sad to say I won’t be back for breakfast due to the high prices and honestly lack of flavor in the bagel! I still will come back to try the pizza but I’m not in a huge rush!

Times Square Pizza & Bagels is officially my favorite pizza joint in the area. While they’ve only been open since sometime last year, the pizza has always been great and the service is on the uptick.
You’ll find it somewhat hidden in low traffic strip mall off of Rancho California Road. That doesn’t stop the populace from finding and frequenting it. Sometimes it will be packed during certain hours, other times it will be less busy in the dining room, but most times they’ll still be filling in delivery orders.
I last came in a couple hours before closing to get a couple of slices for takeout. Though the Unilocal check-​in offer is for first time customers, Sal was nice enough to still throw in a slice and fountain drink on the house as a «night special.» Thank you!
I like that Times Square appreciates the business it gets, and provides great pizza to boot. The Pepperoni is always on point, and the Buffalo and Barbecue Chicken, Hawaiian, and White pizza toppings are pretty good too. Garlic knots are solid and they also serve local craft beer! The NY thin crust here is worth coming back for, but the service itself always gives me a reason to come back as a loyal customer.

Went here recently for the first time. I ordered on a Thursday night, 30 minutes before they were about to close. This was very risky on my part because most places have already closed down the kitchen and started getting ready to close. And a lot of times, employees are just ready to go come for the night, and an order 30 minutes before closing can cause some employees to get upset, or complain.
But… When I called to see if they had an pizza slices left, and if they could whip up a salad to go, the gentleman was very cheery on the phone, and was delighted to make/​prepare my food. This was both surprising and refreshing.
So I ordered 2 slices of the White pizza. And this was very very good pizza! Not the best white pizza I have ever had, but good and local. The manager threw in an extra slice for free since it was at the end of the night and they had exactly 3 pieces left. Thank you!
The large Caesar salad was good. But not great. Could have used a little bit more Parmesan cheese and croutons. Size wise it was decent.
Overall, I would definitely come back for a slice of pie!
Ps. Thank you to the nice gentleman who walked me to the exit and opened the door for me. Very curtious employees.