Nick’s Pizza

This is a standard pizza place with a hit or miss menu. I really like their buff chick calzones but delivery is inconsistent sometimes the food gets to you in 20 minutes and other times it takes up to an hour and a half.

As a former resident of Wellesley who lived there until 1989, one of my cravings every time I come home is the Greek style hamburger and onion pizza. The hamburger is ground up and the taste is so unique. Had the pizza again today and LOVE it. In a Wellesley that has very much changed, Nicks has not and I love them for that. If you are looking for a $ 50 designer pizza go elsewhere. If you want a real traditional style Greek pizza Nicks is the place

It is a simple but honest pizza place. Pleasant and attentive staff. They accommodate my kids requests. I like their veggies pizza. The meatball subs are great. No problem with their delivery service.

The food is actually pretty decent, but I’ve had delivery from them twice now and both times they’ve pretty royally screwed up the order and I’ve had to have them come back and fix it. Not worth the hassle.

Very nice place.
I ordered Nick’s Special and it was really good.

My pizza’s dough was practically raw! It was soaked in grease and completely limp and uneatable. My cheese sticks were fine, but I will not be coming back here

First problem — they forgot my order so when I arrived, there was no pizza. They were nice enough to make one «on the house» but this leads to the Second problem. The pizza was not done completely and we had to basically cook it at home. Not worth going back as there are better options out there.

Tried a couple pies. Hawaiian was great. So was the special.

Nicks is great if you want inexpensive pizza (for Wellesley) with adequate taste. The inside of Nicks is depressing because it hasn’t been updated for at least 20 years. But, besides that, the pizza is good and if you like Greek style pizza, nicks is the place to go.

If you like Greek Style pizza, this is a good place to go. I personally am not a fan of this style, but I still found their pizza enjoyable.
2 slices and a can of soda for under $ 4 is hard to beat for a quick and inexpensive lunch.

I am a student at Babson College. I wish i could order from Town Pizza in Needham but i cant. The calzones are really good but the ones at Town Pizza are even better. I order from here over dominos any day. As for this girl who says its the best crust you have ever had in your life, i think you are exaggerating just a little bit.
The one thing i am disappointed with is the service. They are always rude to me when i try to be nice and it always seems like they do not even want my business.

I have been going to Nick’s since at least the early 1980’s. In fact, I used to work right next to it, so I had many, many vegetarian subs for lunch during that time. If you’re going to Nick’s for the first time, however, get a pizza. My personal favorite is sausage and mushroom. We can talk about toppings all day, but Nick’s has the BEST crust I have ever eaten in my life. Period. It’s light, crunchy, flaky, and delicate. Just DELICIOUS! It’s nothing like these doughy crusts you get everywhere else, laden with a dusting of flour.
And by the way, I believe I am qualified to talk about pizza. I used to live in Italy. And New York.
We just took a trip to Boston, and I announced to everyone: Look, we are going to Nick’s. I HAD to get my fix.
I wish I had photographed my beautiful pizza before I ate it.
The guy who was working was Brazilian, so I thanked him in Italian and Portuguese! LOL.

Lived in Wellesley my whole life and have tried every place around, a few times, and Nick’s is one of the good spots. Sure, it is greasy but that is the best part. The steak and cheese is amazing. Since moving to BC for college I have broadened my pizza-​place horizons, yet Nick’s remains as one of the best around.

Work right near here… their Italian sub is a lunch I can’t go too long without. Pizza is greasy but definitely descent!

I agree with Vivian. If you attend or live in any sort of college or establishment in Wellesley, there is no need to order delivery from the over-​priced, lowest-​quality Dominos or the non-​existent Pizza Hut — choose Nick’s.
While Nick’s doesn’t seem to operate as efficiently as the other two pizza joints, the food they make is probably some of the most disgustingly-​rich/​greasy but most delicious tasting food ever. All their items are conveniently priced.
There are certain specials that are near and dear to many students hearts. For example, the buffalo chicken calzone is a now a cultural phenomenon at Babson. I have yet to meet a person who has not had or tried one.
In conclusion, if you have the urge to clog your arteries after a week of terribly dull and tasteless cafeteria food, Nick’s is the best choice for that late-​night meal that will quench your appetite and satisfy your cravings for the entire weekend.
It is also open late, not as late as Dominos, but college LATE… which is a plus.

Small place in The Hills (of Wellesley, that is). Parking is el-​crapo and pizza is decent. A little too greasy and lightly cooked for my liking (I like my cheese a little crispier, so to speak). Not bad though, I’d probably get delivery from them over Domino’s any day.

Forget Dominos or Pizza Hut, Nick’s is where it’s at.
Their pizzas are on the the thin side, but I prefer the calzones here. The calzones are amazinggggg. Also love that the sausage topping here is real sliced sausage. A large calzone is plenty to share between 2 – 3 and is pretty inexpensive.
Nick’s will also deliver. I’m not sure if they have a minimum, but I’ve definitely had a small calzone delivered to me before.
Nick’s: necessary staple for the college stomach

I love Nick’s. Get the steak bomb sub! Or the calzone. It’s nice and greasy…