Peter’s Pizza

I love Peter’s Pizza. I love the crispy crust and the onion rings. People complain that they have attitude — I’ve never noticed that they’re rude or anything, they just don’t do that fake-​nice customer service thing that I feel like Americans expect everywhere. But the pizza is worth it. So worth it. I wish I lived closer and could order it more often.

You guys are eating the meat from the animals on that wall. Wellesley mass residents really like eating zebra meat. What a down sad town. One day Peter will have your missing pets on that wall.

Very disgusted and disappointed. I regularly order from peters pizza even though they are never pleasant on the phone. However, today will be my LAST. They forgot one of our salads and when we called to inform them we got series ATTITUDE. The man on the phone kept asking if we knew who delivered our food because he had no idea about his employee whom deliver the food. Didn’t have their numbers or anything. Then after he said he would send another salad… it showed up a half hour later, cold and they charged us more for the salad. Terrible customer service.

Local pizza joint. Family run. Descent pies, good for local take-​out.

Peter’s pizza is excellent in our opinion. We order it regularly and find the crust crisp, the toppings generous and the sauce tasty. With a homemade salad to accompany the pie, my family is happy. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Holy cow – we ordered the pizza 2 hours ago, they said it was going to take 30 – 45 minutes to get here and we are STILL waiting. Every time we call they say «sorry but we’re backed up.» That’s it.
Ok, it just arrived… The delivery guy was nice and actually seemed to care, but food is not hot and our night in is kind of ruined (this was movie night with our 5 year old). What a bummer– beware of ordering from them if you want to eat within a timely manner.

Don’t go to Peter’s anymore. It used to be our go to Pizza Place. Last night we ordered a small Pizza and two SMALL salads. Apparently, they don’t have small salads anymore, but the woman taking our phone order did not tell us, so it cost us over $ 21 for a very small pizza and two bad salads. Each salad had precisely two very thin slices of tomato, two very thin slices of cucumber, two small olives and a bit of green pepper. Much of the lettuce had to be thrown away as it was from the core of the head and inedible. Never again.

Peters Pizza is excellent. I have order several large orders before they actually open and they always go out of their way to open up for me and give me a discount.

The food is fine however I can’t get over the photos of the owners pleasure hunts in Africa that were on the walls until the Dentist fiasco zebras antelopes Gazelles moose lions tigers & bears… ohh my I lost my appetite!!!
He must realize the error of his ways the photos have been removed however the stains on the wall remain as well as the blood on his hands.

Excellent food but be advised the menu link on here isn’t accurate. Use the pictures of the menu instead, though the prices have gone up a bit too.

**BUT*** I’m sad to say I won’t be returning to Peter’s again after being a regular customer over the past year. The pizza is great (tho the large is really a medium). The Greek salad is good (also way too small though). The reason that I’m not returning is that I was in there recently and suddenly noticed a wall I’d never seen. It was a wall covered in photos of presumably the owner showcasing all of his many kills as a hunter. There are so many reasons why this is in poor taste not the least of which is upsetting little kids. My kid would be devastated to see him standing proudly over the ZEBRA he killed with his rifle in hand. Just not a good decision. Given how faded they are, I’m sure the photo has been there for years. It’s pretty inappropriate in my opinion.
Will be sorry to not have Peter’s Pizza again.

Never again, 14.95 for a large pepperoni pizza and the pizza was small. $ 2 for a can of soda, $ 20 for a large (small) pizza and 2 cans of soda. It not worth it change the prices or lose business

Excellent pizza with crunchy crust. I recommend extra sauce, because it’s yummy!
Also do hamburgers, subs, wings, and even breakfast sandwiches! All great!
Price is good an service is friendly.
Best pizza in Wellesley hills/​lower falls.

Great pizza. Love the buffalo wings. fast delivery. Steve is great to talk to… plus they are open on sundays!!!

I’ve been here 3 times, and never had a good experience, or food.
Now, I understand they’re a pizza place, and that the food is supposed to be…‘fast’, but there are pizza places that dedicate way less time to individual orders that are at least edible, unlike the few times I’ve ordered from them. Let me walk you through what I’ve been dealing with, each time, reliably.
All three times, I’ve ordered with a group of people I work with, working the later shift. We usually order around 6pm, well before they close, and the food always takes over an hour to get to the building. When ordering, we’re always greeted with sighs, gruff voices, and overall agitation.
The first time I ordered a chicken tender plate; it’s a pretty good baseline that I’ve found for most places I go to for the first time. You can’t mess up a chicken tender plate. Well, this place did. The chicken tenders were kind of warm, and a little soggy on the bottom like they were taken out of the fryer a little too early. The fries were almost cold. When asking the others in the room, they had the same thing with their fries too.
The second time, I thought it was just a fluke, and ordered the same thing again. Same product. Half-​fried chicken tenders, and cold fries. Wonderful.
The third time, I looked through the menu and figured that NOBODY can mess up a grilled cheese kids meal. Come on, it’s for a kid. What did I get? A half-​grilled piece of white bread that was still cool and squishy with a not even melted piece of cheese. The fries were cold, and… I don’t know what I was expecting.
We threw out the menu, it’s just not worth ordering from there if we’re going to be dealing with terrible customer service, and food that’s always poor in quality. Sorry, Peter’s.

Good Very Basic sub and pizza shop. Nothing fancy, just decent food cheap. My dad loves this place, but I think its just ok.

The only reason they get 4 instead of 5 stars is because they aren’t very friendly. Their pizza, however, is SOOO good! Definintely the best I have found in the Wellesley area. It has a great crust with crisp and chew, their sauce is delicious with the perfect blend of sweet and salty, and their cheese and toppings taste fresh. I would definintely recommend for when you have a pizza craving!

Hands down has the best pizza you will ever have in your life. Delivery is free too!

This place moved from the Linden Street location.
Recently, my club got delivery from Pete’s Pizza for a spring kick-​off meeting. Delivery was right on time. The pizza is delicious, and the sauce is especially great. We all enjoyed the large greek salads with yummy dressing. Everything was crisp and fresh. I would definitely recommend this over any other Wellesley pizza establishments!