Vinny’s Pizza

Called and no one picked up. Drove by around 8pm and no lights on. The website is up, but you can’t order and it says they are not currently open. Looks like this place is done.

Would have liked to leave a review, but couldn’t get anyone at the restaurant to pick up the phone to place an order.

They catered a birthday party for us. So much delicious food for a very reasonable price. Best pizza in the area. Huge menu – something for everyone.

Awesome burgers and crazy cheesesteaks. Don’t change it for a thing! Zeppoles are great and good variety of salads. Although some salads are a little pricey. Overall my favorite place in town. Definitely will keep ordering from there.

I’m currently eating a calamari pan pie from Vinny’s. It’s a bit hard to type while eating, but I refuse to put my slice down. I’ve been waiting to try Vinny’s since they opened and I’m mad I waited so long. The crust, sauce, and calamari are all A1. I’ve finally found my go to pizza place, and with free delivery it’s a no brainer. Changing my FB relationship status to Married to Calamari Pizza. Seriously, stop reading and try it now.

Plain cheese pie was spot on – tangy sauce, tasty blend of cheese and just the right balance of the two on a not too thin, not too thick chewy crust. Zeppoles were awesome! Prices were reasonable and the service was quick and pleasant. Will definitely be back to try some of the other items on the menu.

I’ve worked in Roseland NJ for two years now and have been searching for good pizza for quite some time now around the area. I use to work in NYC and love to get myself some good pizza. Me and my co-​workers ordered Vinny’s on a late night shift and let me tell you, the food was fantastic! The buffalo chicken pie was delicious. The pie had the right amount of cheese and ingredients and the buffalo chicken sauce wasnt overpowering which was perfect! We also had a calamari pie and it was simply AMAZING. We also ordered a caprese salad and philly cheesesteak which was also really good. The portions are very generous and we were all extremely satisfied. We will defnitely be ordering Vinny’s more often around the office.

We have eaten there three times and this time we tried delivery. Really impressed! We got a plain pizza, buffalo chicken pizza and eggplant ricotta pizza. The plain is pretty thin (not quite as thing as by the slice, in the store) and the sauce is really good. Eggplant and ricotta is perfect. Eggplant isn’t greasy and ricotta tastes like fresh ricotta (not the commercial kind), My kids and husband had the buffalo chicken. There are red onions on it, tons of chicken and real blue cheese. Try this place! We are pleasantly surprised!

First of all, I’m extremely suspicious when a new place opens, and immediately gets a bunch of 5-​star reviews, especially when some of them are from people who have no other reviews under their names, or from people who don’t live anywhere near the area who would have no reason to visit a local place like this when it first opens.
That said, I have to say that Vinny’s pizza is really good. I’ve resigned myself to the fact that the great places of my youth are gone, along with the people who knew how to make it. But Vinny’s does an admirable job, with sauce that actually tastes like tomatoes (which, more often than not these days, it doesn’t), and a tasty, crisp, non-​bulky crust that doesn’t make you feel bloated after one slice. The toppings are nice and fresh as well. These guys have clearly been in the business long enough to know how to make a pizza that stands out. I’m adding Vinny’s to my short list of 7 006 favorites, along with Tony D’s and La Familia.
I’ll be back.

Great New Place in Caldwell! Lot’s of italian around but this place did not disappoint. We did delivery which came pretty quickly. Chicken Ranch Salad was fresh, big, and crispy. Small Stromboli was as big as a personal pizza and stuffed with fresh veggies and meat. Should have gotten an extra sauce. Great buffalo sauce on the tenders. Zeppoles were handmade and hot — best ones we’ve gotten in a long time.
Definitely will be back to try out there pizzas and pastas.

They don’t open officially till tomorrow (³⁄₂₄) but we got some food delivered.
The crostino (batter-​dipped mozz, stuffed with imported prosciutto and roasted peppers) served with house gravy was amazing. Perfectly cooked, no soggy after delivery and amazing flavor. ⁵⁄₅
The pizza is good. There are about 20 pizza places in Caldwell, Roseland, Monclair & Verona. Vinny does a nice pie. Good crunch, nice and thin, cheese blend is good, crust is perfect. Only complaint was sauce could have more bite. ⁴⁄₅
Wife got a chicken cutlet sandwich. Spot on with thin chicken, mozz, peppers and balsamic. Again, a lot of place do this sandwich locally, but she said it was the best. I think she is being nice. ⁴⁄₅
My Philly Cheesesteak was the bomb. They have a ton of options for cheesesteak; I got mine with steak, cheese, onions & peppers. They do a loaded version with fries I will try next time we order. ⁵⁄₅
Got a cheesecake for dessert. Original style. I wish they made it from scratch, I don’t know if they don’t. It was great ending for the meal. ⁴⁄₅
Overall 4.75.
Sorry Angeloni’s (gross salads and mediocre entrees)
Sorry Russillo (heavy pie crust and entrees are yuck)

I got their menu on my door step & I have to say I was really nervous. Their menu is HUGE!!! I am usually scared of menus so big… hard to be great at so many items. But I love supporting local business & we gave them a try.
I have to say I am BLOWN away. Everything we’ve ordered is amazing. Tonight I was sick so tried the tortellini en brodo soup. If you try one thing, this is a must. I don’t know how they get their broth so rich & delicious.
Their pizza is spot on, sandwiches are amazing & the cheesecake will have you wanting to come back every day. LOVE this place already. Can’t wait to try more.

Great job Vinny. Finally a good local place I can get a classic thin crust pie. I went in for lunch today, I got 2 slices 1 grandma and a plain and I have to say the grandma slice is out of this world. Besides that the employees have a great personality and made me feel welcomed. I’ll be ordering again tonight because I loved it so much. Keep up the good work guys.

I have lived in west Caldwell right across the street from this property for 26 years. I have seen this place change from apontes, to michaels, to sonnys. that being said, to say the very least, vinnys is honestly better than all 3 past businesses combined! I have been going the last 3 days and can only offer my opinion on the pizza which is all I’ve tried so far. I gotta start by informing everyone that they have a brand spanking new oven after getting rid of that ancient old oven of 75 years. I have tried their plain pizza for starters and it is just beyond delicious right down to its soft buttery crust courtesy of the brand new oven. I have tried their chicken parm pizza which was darn good as well. My favorite for now is their cheesesteak pizza made of cheddar, mozerella, steak, and potatoes rather than peppers and onions and it was just perfect! their buffalo pizza was very good and I was full after just one slice of that! cant speak yet for their sandwiches or pasta dishes which I have yet to try. But overall, this is now my favorite pizzeria in the caldwells and you can’t beat their grand opening special of $ 1 plain slices for now. Try them you will thank me later!