Stuft A Burger Bar

Love eating here! Howard and the rest of the staff are amazing. The food is great, and ALWAYS comes just as ordered.

Why is this place consistently serving bad service? Sat down and ordered. Requested an appetizer which is on the flip side of menu which the server did not acknowledge therefore it never arrived. The food then arrived 20 minutes after ordering (these are normal burgers and fries right? Or am I missing something). Food arrived and this is where things get strange. It was lunch time and our server was gone. Not just busy elsewhere, but gone not to be seen again. This place always sounds good, and the burger was great but c’mon! That is actually why it still gets two stars instead of zero. I have given this location multiple chances, and had to finally get this off my chest. Instead, when in Windsor, McDonalds is your best choice.

This is a great idea for a burger place, awesome selection of items to top your burger with. We had garlic Parmesan fries which were yummy.
My only complaint is they went skimpy on the meat, not the size but the quality. With all those great topping options you expect great meat as well and it’s just not. Prepackaged frozen patties. If they step up their game there I would definately gives it 5 stars.
The service was great staff is very friendly.

I have been to Greeley Stuft – but would drive to Windsor just because the service was amazing. Caleb our server was one of the best servers I have had anywhere. I noticed another server Howard? was also great with his customers. Stuft menus and food are the same everywhere, but THIS Stuft stands alone because of the staff. Good job Caleb. You made our day better.

Great place for a burger and a beer at lunch. I had a taste for some red meat so we went here. The place has a nice feel to it and was nicely decorated. Greeted as soon as we walked in by staff and shown to a booth close by the fire. You build your own burger at this place. When we sat down we were given the run down by our friendly waitress on how to complete the burger form. I went with two patties, tomatoes basil goat cheese fried egg and jalapeños on mine sans bun. WOW was that a GREAT burger. They came out pretty fast and just as orders. The beer and wine selection is pretty good. The one negative I have about this place is the level they play their music at. It was loud enough that it was hard to carry on a conversation at our table.

Ok, thought I found a great appetizer in the wingless wing… tonight they were way, way over cooked to the point they were rubbery and of course no succulent taste what-so-ever…the worse part, they aren’t as busy as the other night. Eeeeerrrrr !!

I’ve been to Stuft more time than I can count on both hands, and their food is always consistently good. Typically when we have out of town company, this is where I’ll bring them 1) Because their food is unique and excellent and 2) It’s a good excuse to have a great burger and beer.

It was just okay. the burger was pretty good. Fries were soggy and coldish. probably wont go again

This was my first time ever dining here so I didn’t know what to expect. The food was good, but the service was far from it. I chose the «little pink» option for my burger and it turned out to be «a lot of pink». Our waitress wasn’t attentive at all. Our drinks sat empty most of dinner, and our table was covered with dishes that should’ve been taken away. I’ll try this food chain one more time, but definitely not this location.

I ordered a sweet tea — it was terrible; hardly sweet at all, tasted watered down and bitter. I didn’t say anything, just decided to drink my water instead.
When we got the bill I saw that they charge 50 cents extra for sweet tea! What a rip off!

Pretty underwhelming to say the least! Try sweeping your entrance for starter then advise your waitstaff to not smell like a ashtray.
Had the slider sampler and meat too overcooked sand dry, very disappointing and the Parmesan garlic fries please try again.
The Texas Two Step burger was average. Meat overcooked as well. The cinnamon bacon was a good touch, but please use a lettuce leaf and not shredded lettuce!
The final two failures of this place is no salt and pepper on the table and a pushy waitress who wanted to pick the check up to see her tip. Never will go back ! We visited 7−25−15 at 2:30pm. Sorry we didn’t take pictures!

I really want this place to be good but it is… not. It is a very expensive burger that is very bland. The meat was flavorless and the bun a little on the stale side. The fries were cold and the milk shake was very thin.

This place was great love the atmosphere TVs on the walls sports playing the food was great the service is great our server harold was exceptional Informative and helpful I highly recommend this restaurant

Good burgers and sandwiches. A little on the expensive side but worth it. They also have a decent selection of beer.

Extremely helpful staff for a Stuft noob as myself. Love the idea of creating your own burger and then naming it. Excited to try a glazed donut for a bun.
Once the food got to our table and we took our first bite… meh. Pretty disappointing to say the least. No flavor. Something different about the beef pattys. Either they are using ⁹⁰⁄₁₀ beef, adding breading or they are manhandling the meat too much (insert joke here). I was expecting a juicy burger (ordered medium) and it was far from it. I squeezed the burger and no fat seeped out. Very stiff and dry.
Maybe my expectations were set too high for an All-​American burger. This is just a bad example of it.
It is a really clean, friendly place. Food is just sub-​par… like a cold, flavorless burger you would get at Red Robin. Also VERY expensive! Two burgers, two fries and two cokes = $ 28.00. No thank you. I make better burgers at home.
**MESSAGE TO THE BUSINESS MANAGER**
05/​17/​2015
Thanks but no thanks. I highly doubt you can help me. Getting a free meal or a second opportunity won’t change my mind. I really don’t like your burgers and they are not worth going out of my way for. You’re reviews are VERY inconsistent which usually means mismanagement. Plenty of opportunities to grow, right?

Love the staff and food at Stuft. Howard always has a smile on his face and our favorite waitress April makes us laugh and keeps us coming back. We are hooked.

Love this place! Went last night on a busy Friday night. Always consistent food, clean and great service. My husband and I sat at the bar. Heather and Jake were spot on. They were very friendly and professional. Both bartenders multi-​tasked perfectly, all customers around us were very happy which is nice to see as busy as they were. My husband loves the burgers. My favorite is the fried pickles. Great beers.
Would love some drink and food specials especially during key games like Broncos, Avalanche, Eagles etc…

Howard is amazing, he should be the manager and then the place would be great.
It’s obvious the current manager can’t handle it, GO HOWARD!

I was in here on Sunday evening for dinner with 4 of my family members. The menu is easy to understand. you can order a pre designed burger or make your own. The options are plentiful and the server can’t mess up your order since you fill it out on paper yourself. The prices are reasonable and they have a little something for everyone. My little brother got The Hangover which consists of glazed doughnuts for a bun and he loved it. I opted for more traditional and it was still a great burger. We ordered nachos to start with and I could have done without them. Potato chips with cheese whiz, tomatoes, olives, chives and sour cream were blah. If they had used actual cheese I feel that these would have been significantly better. The tv’s at every table and around the restaurant make this a good spot for catching a game.
Overall we had a pleasant experience. Although I will say we had a brand new server (she told us) and she needed more training. When my hand is still on the appetizer plate, no, I am not done with it. She acted very nervous and made things pretty awkward at times, but luckily most of us have waited tables and shrugged it off.

It was a Sunday late afternoon and we were hungry and in the mood to try something new. We had not been to Stuft A Burger before so decided to visit the one in Windsor for dinner. The place was decorated nicely and was clean and bright. The tv’s at each booth were a nice touch too. We received prompt, friendly service. We each ordered veggie burgers with different toppings. We liked that you use a sheet to create your order so you can easily customize your burger.
I ordered fries and a veg burger with aged cheddar, mayo, lettuce, tomato, raw onion, caramelized onion, nitro milk stout onion straws and asked for some mustard and mayo to add on as needed. The food looked good enough when it arrived but the first bite of the burger revealed a really bland tasting burger. It wasn’t bad tasting, just really bland which is surprising with all of the flavorful toppings I’d had added — it should have had HUGE taste but it didn’t. Even my 11 year old son commented how little flavor his veg burger had.
You can pick 4 basic toppings that are included in the price of your burger and then any above and beyond that cost extra. I decided to get an extra topping and to go ahead and pay for a «premium» topping that costs more than the standard toppings because the nitro milk stout onion straws sounded good. Now, I don’t have an issue with paying extra for something if it is reasonable, tastes good and is a decent portion for what you get — I was disappointed as the toppings were very skimpy, especially for paying a $ 1 extra for the nitro milk stout onion straws as I had to hunt around to even find any — there were maybe 3 little strips total, each the size of a matchstick and that sure doesn’t look like $ 1 worth of toppings to me!
They charge extra for the fries so just the burger and fries before you add extra stuff to the burger ends up running your burger up to more than the gourmet burgers cost at Red Robin or Gunther Toody’s so at this point you’re expecting an excellent burger! The fries are okay buf not the best I ever had and they arrived luke warm which was disappointing.
Overall not a real impressive meal for anyone in our family. As I said, it wasn’t bad tasting — just wasn’t anything that tasted great or stood out — very mediocre food which was a bummer as we were hoping to add another place to our list of choices when we want to go out for a bite. This is not a place I’d go out of my way to visit again just based on the price of the food and the lack of flavor alone.