Original Pizza

Pizza is good. Staff is fast and friendly. Get the pizza to go because once the high school gets out its crowded. The place is clean and there is always pizza on the counter. He should make more of a variety of pizza like everyone else is doing. Overall if you need a quick slice on 4^th avenue, hit them up.

Grew up in bay ridge eating original pizza, still travel over an hour and a half from Philadelphia for that perfect cheese slice. They don’t make pizza that crispy with the perfect sauce and amount of cheese anywhere else.

Grandma slice is my favorite! Also it’s in the perfect location! You can grab a quick bite before getting on or off the bus or train.

This place has the best pizza in Bay Ridge, possible the best pizza in Brooklyn! The sauce and cheese ratio is perfect. The crust is perfect, nice and crispy. Everything is perfect! Delivery is also fast.

3.5 stars!
Pretty decent slice. Thin, crispy and piping hot. Can’t complain. I’ll definitely be coming here more.

Came here to grab some late night pizza a little before they were closing. Was a little weird since most pizza shop display their pizza. Their pizza was kinda hiding under the counter and not much selections. Either it was going to be a regular slice or a sicilian.
Ordered one of each. The taste is better than your typical corner pizza joint. Had a good balance of cheese and sauce. The regular slice pizza was so thin. I kind of felt like I ate nothing after eating that slice. Probably would take many slice for me to get full. The sicilian slice was delicious also but on the small side.
The pizza is good from this place but just didn’t really like how they got so little selections and the pizza is not too filling compared to other places.

after a train ride, this is my spot.
garlic knots? yes please.
love this place. love it to death. i only ever have pizza or garlic knots, so i can’t attest to anything else, but their pizza and garlic knots are TOP NOTCH.
slice that is. their plain slice is top notch.
not so much their Sicilian slice. not unless you ask for it to be extra hot and crispy.

Suprised it took it this long to goto this neighborhood pizzaria! If I didn’t miss my bus, I wouldn’t have step in, I’ve been going to Ricky’s closer to my apt but it has been very disappointing lately. The service was quick, and there are plenty of seats if you decide to stay. the crust is thin and crispy, w right amount of cheese and tomatoes sauce, simple and satisfying!

I LOVE their pizza, I live down the block however lately I have had stomach issues after eating there. they should wear gloves to handle the money — I think that’s what is causing my distress. sad because the pizza is great.

I love Original Pizza… I assume all of them are a chain… because the square pie is the same dough in each place. I really only get the square pie — either regular (sauce and cheese) or with the fresh mozzarella/​tomato. I can’t explain it… the crust is so light and airy. Pure Heaven!!! Also, the margherita round pie is sooo good too.

I drive from Queens just to have a couple of slices here. From the first bite into the hot-​out-​of-​the-​oven, not too thin/​not too thick crust holding enough melted mozzarella cheese that seems to stretch and stretch and refuses to detach off the crust to the flavorful sauce (I’ve experienced sauces which are too salty, this is perfect), it brings me back to my days of youth in Brooklyn, going to the pizzeria for a slice for $.50 (really, I’ve aged myself here) after school. This is true Brooklyn pizza to me, someone who grew up in Brooklyn. It’s a good thing I don’t live in the neighborhood, otherwise I’d be large, round and lumpy from a steady diet of pizza because the smell of it baking is enough to draw me in.
On two occasions, I thought they closed down (store was shuttered) and it seemed impossible to find another pizzeria serving slices as good (even Ray’s original doesn’t taste so original anymore) but thankfully, they still stand on that 4^th avenue corner open for service. As long as they are there and don’t change the recipe, I will always make time to drive in from Queens just to get that delicious slice down memory lane.

the best slice –plain-​in Brooklyn or NYC for that matter. it’s a no frills setting but who is going for the ambiance– go for the slice!!!

The pizza here is really good, one of the best in the neighborhood and the prices are better than a lot of the nearby pizza places.
If you’re reading this, please start serving wings!

very good pizza… unpretentious…delicious…at the corner next to the R train stop at Bay Ridge Ave… real Bklyn. pizza
Update: Two things:
1 — Try their «Supreme» pizza. It’s made with homemade mozzarella, etc. — and is even better than their regular great pizza: sooooooooooo fresh — and like being in Italy. You usually have to order it ahead of time (it’s not just their by the slice usually). But a whole «supreme» pie is $ 14, I think.
2 — Also — I didn’t realize til recently that they’re run by the same people who run My LIttle PIzzeria down on Court St. near Atlantic — used to get pizza down there all the time (everyone who works in Downtown Bklyn near Borough Hall — goes there — or to Monty’s on Montague) — both great pizza shops!
The staff is really nice, too (in the shop and for delivery).

Best place in Bay Ridge to go for a slice! Thin, tasty, sauce is just right. Plus, they often have fresh basil leaves!

Delicious NY styled pizzas here. Love the taste, and the crunchy crust texture.

Delicious & inexpensive NY styled pizza! Love the taste and texture of their cheese slice. The mozarella cheese and sauce they use are to die for. Love their crust the most! Highly Recommended!

This is a pretty busy place, the pizza is okay. What I really like here is the white pizza slices, the mozzarella cheese and ricotta are so yummy.
I have tried the regular slices they are fine but the best slice to me is the white. Just the flavor and texture without the sauce so good. Plenty of seating and friendly service.

The BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD. And right outside my train station too! =))))) Thin and crunchy crust, mozzarella that actually stretches (know what I’m talking about???), and THE SAUCE. Seriously the PERFECT pizza slice every time I come here, and I’ve been coming here since my age was in the single digits. You have to try it to believe it. Every other slice of pizza I’ve had, no matter how fancy or expensive, has paled in comparison. I did notice that their garlic knots keep getting smaller and smaller — they’re practically bite size if you have a big enough mouth, but THE SAUCE makes up for it. I’m not a fan of toppings when it comes to pizza, so I always get the plain cheese. Let me reiterate — it’s PERFECT.
Go try it.

Thank God for Original Pizza. Seriously. Bay Ridge seems to have a pizzeria on every block, and yet not a single place, aside from Espresso (which, sadly, is outside my delivery zone), and Original, is consistently good. Not a single one. And when I say good, I mean *good*. Nicely charred on the bottom, thin crust, perfectly seasoned sauce, and great tasting cheese. After being let down many times from other pizzerias, this is the only place within delivery range of my apt. that I’ll order from (hopefully I’m not jinxing myself by typing this!)
Looking forward to trying their non-​pizza dishes!