Mountain Mike’s Pizza

Great food! Great price!

This place! Oy! First… their pizza is always delicious. I am a pepperoni lover and Mountain Mike’s totally satisfies that craving. They have the little pepperonis that kind of curl up when they cook and make these perfect little pepperoni grease cups that are phenomenal! Second… their beer selection is always on point. I am an IPA kinda girl and they have 10 handles of nothing but craft beer, half of which are some kind of IPA. This place is FIRE! Third… they are always offering discounts to their patrons. ½ price beers from 2 – 6 EVERY DAY! 40% off large pizza on tuesdays. Hell they even have a rewards program where you enter you phone # and earn points for your purchases. Not to mention how friendly the owner and his staff are. They totally earn those 5 stars and then some. I’ve been coming here for years… well since they were at Madison and Fair Oaks… and will continue to do so. Best pizza and beer spot in Fair Oaks/​Citrus Heights/​Orangevale hands-​down!

I go here a few times a month and have never had a bad pizza. The restaurant is always clean and the people are friendly. Never been here before? You should definitely try the McKinley! Best pizza ever!

This has been my favorite pizza place for over 20 years. I have been coming to this Mt. Mike’s since it was at Fair Oaks and Madison. Paul has been one of the kindest and most service oriented small business owners I have known.
The last time I was in there I mentioned that my wife is on a special diet and when I mentioned her needs he told me to let him know beforehand and he would do everything he could to accommodate her diet.
I just returned from 15 years in Southern California and I’ve been eating here pretty much once a week.
Do yourself a favor and try the pepperoni and olive pizza. You will love it or I’ll eat it. Seriously I will eat it if you don’t.

Best pizza, salad bar is always stocked full and fresh, super clean, ice cold beer and angry orchard on tap, great neighborhood service. We’ve been coming here for years.

!! Excellent speedy service! The garlic breadsticks are amazing! We’re kind of picky about our pizza and this place has it! Awesome! Definitely coming back to the Fair Oaks location again! Almost makes me glad for the bad service we got at the place we just left down the parking lot… this is way better!

I’ve lived here for 26 years and just discovered there is a Mountain Mikes a block away, no clue how long it’s been there. I discovered it through the Unilocal app and discovered you get 20% off, so we decided to give it a try. I’m in bed today from back pain so I called to get a carry out order. All we wanted is a large pepperoni pizza with gluten free crust and to use the discount. Well the gluten free crust only comes in a small, seriously? How do you charge $ 12 for a small and only have a small if we all (being 3) need gluten free? I have to order 3 pizzas for $ 36 and I can’t use the coupon. I don’t even want to go into the long phone call conversation with a guy who barely spoke English just to make the order. This is ridiculous and they better hope the pizza tastes as good as it costs or we will stick with home made gluten free.

My sister-​in-​law loves the pizza here, and when we’re up for a visit, she’ll usually get one of the chicken/​white sauce ones. She’s really picky about pizza and loves theirs. (And has tried pretty much every pizza place in town.) Usually I’m left out, since I can’t eat wheat, so I was pleasantly surprised to find MM’s has gluten free crusts now. (I can finally eat a slice instead of just oogling theirs, LOL!)
Far as GF goes, this pizza is pretty decent. I just had the cheese, and it only comes in small. I think it’s pretty good, but I don’t normally eat anything GF that’s a version of the «real-​deal» (like pizzas, donuts, bread, etc-​because usually they’re terrible! :)) It has a thin crust and was well cooked, as in not too pale, not too dark. I got just cheese because it’s a luxury to have something all to myself… everybody else always wants a million toppings, and I’m a purist I suppose! (Weird, yes, but I miss my real NY pizza. Just cheese. Oregano sprinkles, that’s it.)
I know they have amazing pizzas at MM, you can have them anyway you want-​and they come in all sizes, from small to extra-​party-​people-​huge. They top them fresh and have great coupons on the box and in the mail. This particular location is always spic and span and the veggies, toppings, and salads look super fresh.
Now that the GF crust is unleashed, I know I’ll be back for more than just a great salad! Thanks, guys!
TIP:
Plenty of free parking out front. :) Hey Sacto, for us LA peeps, that’s a serious asset!
We usually call ahead and pop over to get it right out of the oven… always perfect.
Look in the mail for the coupons, they really send out some worth using!

It’s consistent quality of pizza and service makes me turn it to 5 stars. Restaurant is always clean when we visit and salad bar is fresh.

Spent $ 40 on a couple pizza. One was under cooked and the other was burnt. They wouldn’t give me a refund. Thanks.

My husband and I love the curry pizza it’s the best and every time we go in it’s always great service and the people working are always super nice and the restaurant is always clean. Best place to get pizza at and its worth the drive.

Most chain pizza places I avoid, Mountain Mike’s and Roundtable are two exceptions. Mtn Mike’s consistently produces quality pizza at a decent price.
The pizza crust is cooked very well with a good crunch, generous portion of toppings. My favorite specialty pizzas are Everest (classic combo), Pikes Peak (all meat) and Pinapple Chicken Luau. Try the creamy garlic white sauce, it is delicious.

There’s no option for negative stars or else I’d give 5 of them. Just called to order a pizza for delivery at 4:58pm on a Saturday. I advised the guy that answered that I have a coupon for a buy one large speciality pizza at regular price and get a 1 topping large pizza for free. The guy stated they don’t have that option available for delivery when the coupon clearly stated they do but not after 5 pm on Friday and Saturday. It’s clearly before 5 at this point. The guy then stated that it would take 45 mins to deliver which is past 5??? Wow, never had a place of business try to get out of honoring a coupon that they committed to. I highly recommend going to a place other than this place as they refused to honor something they committed too.

The BEST Mountain Mike’s Pizza in area! There are 2 on Sunrise, make sure you get to this one at Madison.
It is always clean. Pizza is always perfect, with generous amount of toppings. My son said they have really good pepperoni, and claim 100 slices of pepperoni on a large pizza, we ordered a pizza with ½ pepperoni. There were 50 slices of pepperoni on the ½, amazing.
Would have given 5 stars, but they close down the salad bar by 8:30 at night. I feel if your location closes at 10 pm, the salad bar should be open until at least 9:30.

Curry Chicken Pizza! Had some at a poker party; it was a hit with everybody. Took my wife to try it again. We weren’t disappointed. Fresh and delicious. The pizza was beautiful (all those colors!). And this is the cleanest Mountain Mike’s I’ve ever been in.

Tuesday 40% off for pickup!!!
ordered a large pepperoni, they added mushrooms for me no charge
very clean in a nice easy to park strip mall, right next to trader joes
quick fast, no hassle no fuss. they had espn on the flat screen for your pleasure!

I just tried to order a pizza online, but couldn’t find a coupon code so I called to find out how to apply it.
I was informed, not very politely, that the store isn’t connected to the online, so the girl told me to order on the phone.
I proceeded to order on the phone and the girl sounded irritated when I had to figure out which pizza and to go find my card to pay. which is why I was ordering online, since I didn’t have my order organized yet.
The girl that was taking my order wasn’t very polite or courteous, and made me feel bad for ordering.

Our end of soccer season party was scheduled at 6pm so I thought I’d be smart and call our order in an hour ahead of time so it would be ready when we arrived. Even after the long wait in line to pay, my order was not ready and they had run out of Stella on tap. They knew there was a large party scheduled, but they didn’t have enough staff to keep up with the demands. Our order was brought to our table long after the orders of the people who had ordered when they arrived. They knew they had messed up and still did nothing to try and remedy it, such as offering free sodas or coupon for a later date… anything would have been nice just as a show of good faith. Mountain Mike’s is still my favorite pizza, but this location failed this time.

Let me preface this with saying that I’ve been a Mountain Mike’s fan for a long time. Love their pizza and especially the pepperoni pizza. Have had it at many different locations and the pies they dish out have always been good.
With that said, this location delivered me a pizza that wouldn’t even compare to a Little Caeser’s Hot’n’Ready that’s been sitting for an hour. Tasted like complete crap. Something must’ve gone wrong. Burnt pieces on the crust, barely any cheese and stale ass pepperoni. I just can’t wrap my head around how bad they made this pizza. It’s definitely a first for Mountain Mike’s in my experience.
I’ll still remain a fan of their pizzas, but I’ll never go back to this location.

I don’t know what kind of crack the previous reviewers were smoking, but pizza does not get better than this. The only thing I can think of is maybe they were under different management? Pizza dough was cooked to perfection, crispy yet soft. Topping were generous. Salad bar was fully stocked with fresh produce. Facility was clean, looks newly remodeled.
Only complaint is Mountain Mikes tend to be a little pricey, but I’ll pay for perfect pizza. Divine!