Evelyn’s

The staff was friendly from start to finish. Our food arrived in about 5 minutes and it was really good. I had the chicken quesadilla and my husband got the blackened mahi sandwich and fries. Both were delicious!

My review is for breakfast. I have not tried any of the Mexican dishes but they have plenty.
The breakfast was perfect. Eggs, cheese and bacon on a croissant that can’t be beat. The hashbrowns were done well as requested and the OJ tasted fresh. The coffee was good too. Service was friendly and timely. Wouldn’t change a thing.

Stopped here on our way to our hotel to grab lunch and it was a good find. The place is small has inside and outside seating but the food was great. Big breakfast and lunch selections to choose from. The staff was really nice also

Just down here for a week doing the tourism stuff. Stopped in for lunch with family. It was great. Liked it so much came back 3 days later and each of us ordered something different. Adult family of 7 and everyone loved it. Each dish is around $ 8 – 9.

Incredibly slow service. After waiting for 30 minutes and inquiring about our food, they didn’t even start cooking it yet. There was no wait, plenty of free tables, we even called ahead… The waitress wasn’t even coming around to fill our water. So, when it came to either missing our snorkeling trip or waiting another 15 – 20 minutes for food, we obviously left. Lots of restaurants with similar style food here, no reason to settle for such poor service.

We stopped here on our way to Key West. What a great meal! Evelyn’s offers indoor or outdoor dining. Food and service was great. My husband LOVED his mahi-​mahi sandwich and his onion rings. We would definitely stop there again. Kids are welcome. Alcohol served as well.

Amazing breakfast! We eat here as much as possible they spoil my babies too with their Mickey pancakes!

This is perfect if you are looking for a «local diner» experience. We had breakfast at Evelyn’s. The service was friendly and the food was tasty!
The diner has a lot of character but it is small. Outside dining is available with several tables under cover. I had the Huevos rancheros for breakfast. It came with shredded hash browns (which I always love with diner breakfasts). The portion size was HUGE. I recommend sharing this dish if you aren’t a big eater.
Have fun!

Great place for breakfast! Make your own omelets was a nice feature. Not too familiar with gluten-​free needs. I wish they would study up on this and provide a gf menu.

One of the few places that has chicken fried steak! I live here and dont really like seafood so i love that everything tastes like its suppose to and not with a hint of fish ;)

I went for lunch. I had the Seafood sampler which was very fresh. the clam chowder was thick with clumps of clam. I tried the lime Margarita tasty and refreshing.

Stopped in for supper with my family of five after a full day of snorkeling. We’re planning on something with seafood but ended up getting a burger some Mexican some fish tacos some breakfast food and the Mahi basket. Everyone cleaned their plates and really enjoyed their meals. We’re really pleased with this choice of restaurants. Thanks Unilocal

On our drive from Ft. Lauderdale to Key West, my husband and I needed a place for a drink and bit to eat and stopped here because it was the first restaurant we spotted upon entering the Keys. We chose cracked conch, grilled mahi mahi with onion rings, and a slice of key lime pie. It was all delicious.
The menu is quite varied-​seafood and mexican with a range of prices. Service is very friendly.

We were looking for a quick cheap breakfast on the way home from a keys trip. Randomly stopped in here. Besides being quick and cheap… service was great and more importantly the food was delicious. It’s not gourmet but it’s very good for the money you’re paying.

A friend of mine had recommended us to try this place so we did. The waitress was very kind and attentive but the food was only mediocre. I tried the ribeye with fried shrimps; steak was not that tasty and the shrimps not crisp, the calamari reminded us of those cheap ones from the supermarket. The food for the four of us was $ 80, but comparing our experience to a previous night at nearby Mrs. Macs I’d rather pay the extra $ 20 dollars to Mrs. Macs.

If your in the mood for Mexican while your in key largo, this is the place to go! Clean hole in the wall with an extremely nice wait staff
Excellent Enchiladas!
We will be back!

It’s a classic diner that serves breakfast all day long. However, sadly, I wasn’t craving breakfast food and got the grilled mahi sandwich instead. Service was a tad slow, but the food came out super hot, so that was a definite bonus. Was the sandwich anything fancy that I’ve never had before? No, but it was delicious and definitely fresh. Would absolutely be back if I’m ever in the area again.

I’m from Texas, and like to think I know Mexican food. I go into shock if my cheese level gets too low: p. This is an awesome place. I was a little surprised by the cost, it was a little pricier than I’m used to for Mexican food, but it was really good, so I’ll say it was money well spent. And it was probably cheap for Keys prices. Service was fast and friendly. Beans were fresh, rice and salsa were homemade; the biggest surprise was that the crispy taco shells were homemade. Not many places do that.
I wish I could try some other menu items, but I guess it will have to wait until my next trip!

Patty Melt Heaven with Hand Battered Onion Rings! Absolutely delicious! On a recent dive trip to the Keys, we stopped here on the way home. Great service and good food! I just wish they would make the patio area non-​smoking~

This is my breakfast go to spot when I am in Key Largo. The breakfast menu is varied with the American standbys to Mexican and fusion. I have not settled on a favorite yet, each new item I try is always cooked perfectly, with one exception. One time the beans served on the side were luke warm to room temperature; normally they are perfect. Some of the delicious breakfasts that I have had there include; waffles with strawberries, chorizo tacos, huevos rancheros, Mediterranean omelet, farmers omelet, breakfast burrito and western omelet.
I had lunch on the outdoor patio once and it was exposed to the breeze with very little noise from the road. It was decorated nicely and seemed like it would be a good place to have dinner or drink a few at night in the winter. I had my service dog there and the staff were very accommodating.
This is one of the few family run operations where there isn’t an incompetent family member that ruins the business. The staff are always friendly, even when busy. It appears that the majority of their customers for breakfast are regulars; they can’t afford to live off of tourist business.
When coming from the north the business is hard to spot. Go slow when near and look for the sign.

Einfacher diner mit robuster aber freundlicher Bedienung. Ich hatte ein seafood buritto für 12 USD. In dem waren — hallo — drei Jakobsmuscheln und einige große shrimps enthalten sowie Filet vom Mahi-​Mahi. Die Muscheln und die Shrimps keine Tiefkühlware, sondern alles frisch. Wunderbar. Dazu etwas Salat und einige Saucen: Tomatensalsa, Saure Sahne, grüné Chilisauce. Wirklich nicht schlecht. Die Begleitung hatte einen Salat (ähnlich Cesar) und frittierte Mozzarellasticks. Einfach, aber OK. Gerne wieder.