Fat Tuesday

Honestly this place would be 5 stars if it was just for the drinks. $ 1 Jell-​O shots and of course their big frozen drinks which are awesome. However it’s not just about the drinks. It wasn’t crowded when I was there and one of the bartenders, don’t know her name on a couple of occasions «didn’t realize» the customer gave her a large bill and would short change them unless they said something. Maybe she was just a little ditzy but something seemed up.
Also wtf is wrong with the men’s room I get it, no one wants to clean the bathroom but it was beyond disgusting. There was green shit running down the walls, the bathroom beyond reeked of urine and there was some nasty fungus starting to take over.
Basically go for the drinks, watch your cash and go somewhere else to go to the bathroom.

Frozen drinks=brain freeze. This is a pretty popular spot to stop by. I wouldn’t stay there long. Just grab your beverage and go. Drinks are strong, so if I you are looking to pre-​game this is the spot. It was slow on the night I went but the bartender did not tend much to us. I even called one over and got ignored. Good spot to stop by on a hot day to cool down. The music was good the time I was there.

Popular spot on Duval Street and the service is excellent, very friendly and personable staff. Just really enjoyed their frozen drink, ‘Pain In The Ass’, it’s a combination of a Rum Runner and a Pina Colada, with an extra shot of 151. Highly recommend it.

Great place to stop on a hot day to cool
off with a frozen adult beverage! Nothing made this place stand out though. I went during the day in the early afternoon. I ordered the ultimate margarita and had two of them… the first was was very good but the second one tastes like all lime juice…3 drinks equaled $ 32

Not a busy spot during the week, and our service was good. The drinks were typical Fat Tuesday style and delicious. Happy hour is $ 2.50 off of the regular price and worth it for sure.

This place is perfection. Okay, I only came in here, got a drink a few times, and left so I didn’t really get to «experience» it, but the drinks are perfection. I bought a bottle with a koozie for $ 11 with $ 7 refills. With the shot of Bacardi (which they don’t tell you is an extra $ 1.50 or so), taxes, and tips, it ends up being a $ 10 refill anyway. First I had the Hurricane, then the Peachtree Bellini, then the Pain in the Ass. They were all SO GOOD, but especially the Pain in the Ass and Peachtree Bellini. They were all made with just the right amount of alcohol and the serving size is ample– I was pretty drunk after 3 (I’m also a 105 lb 5’4″ 21 year old). I was served quickly each time and IDed every time as well. Next time I’m in Key West, I’ll definitely come back here! In fact, I’ll probably buy some of their drink mixes online :)

Had a lot to choose from. You could walk the streets with your drinks too.

Fat Tuesday was awesome! The strawberry daiquiri was amazing!!! Bought the cup with 7.00 refills. def worth it! Would def go back here for the strawberry daiquiri. :)

OMG the drinks are delicious. I think I sampled then all… Love this place. Had the mango tango. With an extra shot.

This place is perfect for that refreshing, frozen drink you’ve been dreaming about. It hit the spot & did not disappoint. There’s not much to see in the bar, but enjoy your drink then move on to your next spot.

My wife and I were here probably 7 yrs ago and it is still awesome. When it is super hot out there frozen drinks are like alcohol infused slurpees (for my 7−11peeps). Always get the floater.

I’ve been to many Fat Tuesday’s and this one was the best hands down! Was similar to a night club and had great drinks!

Great place to just chill and people watch. I had to come here after seeing the Fat Tuesday’s bike riding down the street with music blaring. Their frozen drinks are a great relief after walking in the hot and humid Florida weather all afternoon. They have bathrooms on site which is always a plus. The reviews about the creepy people did make me laugh because it’s true but hey, what can you expect?

Having finally stepped foot into Fat Tuesday this weekend after all these years I was pleasantly surprised. With a few steps up to this open air corner bar on the corner of Duval and Rose Lane (across from Caroline’s), it is no doubt a college town bar.
Along the left side is one long bar with a host of different frozen drink machines with accompanying menu’s above. There are also well drinks & beer along with a few high tops and chairs. A D.J. booth is to the right diligently spinning the latest dance/​pop music.
The tempo was high energy with dancing and groups of people enjoying themselves. I did taste a friend’s frozen drink and it was way too sweet for me, so I would ask to see if you can get a small taste before you buy a particular flavor. I’m not sure if they will do that, but it’s worth a shot.
Nothing fancy by any means. Just a cool little island joint with lots of energy. For me personally it is on the younger side but if I had the opportunity and was in the mood, I would definitely drop in for a shot and a dance again.
It was a fun time.
Average age range: 21 — 35

You already know what your getting into when you come here — complete shit show. The beers are reasonably priced (at least coming from Miami) and the music usually banging. However, this is the place you must wear some sort of foot condom — or you will get an STD.
Enjoy your boozy slushy and then take off. Place is good to start or end at — but don’t try spending your whole night here. Better places to fill your time.

WOMEN PLEASE BEWARE.
I came here with a girl & guy friend and had one drink after working all day. I was dancing with my two friends when some creep came up and grabbed my butt under my dress. We told the security guard, who then high fived the guy that sexually harassed me, shook his hand, and introduced him to the DJ booth. Isn’t the entire point of a security guard to keep everyone safe at the venue? So at Fat Tuesday’s in Key West creeps will be rewarded.
We then politely asked for the manager to inform him about the situation. The manager, Dan Wukotich, smirked sarcastically — also approving of the situation and did nothing about it.
We then went to Rick’s Bar, where the SAME creep came up and sexually harassed my friend vengefully and with a entitled smile on his face. The security guards saw what happened, and tastefully and immediately handled the situation, by escorting him out of the bar. It took about 3 security guards since he was fighting back at them, but they handled the situation with integrity and morale. The same way you’d treat the situation if it was your sister, mother, daughter, or any other human being.
The point is Fat Tuesday’s in Key West is a sketchy place with twisted/​unprofessional staff/​management and I’d simply like to give you a heads up to let you know that you are absolutely NOT safe there. Bring your business to any other bar in Key West. If not, you have been warned.

Daiquiris and dancing! This is a good spot for a frozen drink on a hot day. Their drinks are very tasty and there is always fun music playing. In my younger years I spent a lot of time here. As I get older it has become more of a stop in for a quick drink and keep crawling spot for me. Still, the drinks are good and the atmosphere is fun.

I don’t care that it’s a cheesy tourist bar, I love it. I think it has some of the best people watching around with beautiful bartenders and 55+ age patrons ogling them. My favorite flavors are mudslide and hurricane. Waitstaff is always pleasant and we’ve never waited to get a drink here.

I will admit I would never stop at a Fat Tuesday, unless someone I’m with wants to go. Well of course that happened since some random dude who was buying my friend and myself drinks took us here. There were only 2 positives I can say from the experience, the place was clean and we got served really quickly. The 2 positives is why they get 2-​stars as well. Besides those 2 positives, I thought the drinks were way to sweet and lacking really any distinct flavor. I also thought the drinks were overpriced for what they were. Shockingly this place closes up early on a Monday night. I think we were kicked out at 1am even though the place had people buying drinks.
If you aren’t into frozen drinks from a machine, this place is definitely not for you! Find somewhere else to go on Duval Street since this place is way to commercial. I most likely will never come back here unless someone else drags me to it again.

Good place to walk in grab a frozen drink, dance, and have fun with your friends. Our group stopped here many times during our visit. We loved this place. I am not a big drinker and slow to drink so I enjoyed that my drink was frozen and served in an insulated container. You have several options to choose from, but I mainly stuck with the sex on the beach slushee. It was refreshing after our walks and not too stout.
I was pleased with our service each time I stopped in. They servers were friendly and always offered me a sample to try. I agree with them being pricey, but what isn’t pricey in that particular area?