Frosty Rock Creamery

The best homemade ice cream in the Hudson Valley !!
The deep fried ice cream was unbelievable! !!

2 stars because the ice cream is great, and usually the girls at the counter are friendly enough (not shining examples of stellar service, but decent), but whoever was closing up today has a real attitude problem and should either get additional training or just straight up fired.

In general I love ice cream… staff is inviting and very friendly. The chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream in a waffle cone is heavenly delicious. The simple vanilla soft serve with rainbow sprinkles is also very good. For the amount of ice cream we are given the prices are reasonable.

Well-​prepared, well-​balanced delicious ice cream. The soft is not homemade but there are so many terrific flavors of hard ice cream that I wasn’t at all tempted to get soft serve here. (I think the variety and preparation is better than the popular creamery with the view in Warwick.) Delectable!

YUM!!! (My favorite word).
The home made ice-​cream at Frosty Rock Creamery is delicious!!!
My favorite is the Oatmeal-​Cookie ice-​cream. We tried the following flavors:
— Funfetti (Vanilla with sprinklers (A hit for the kiddos)
— Banana — If you really like Banana flavor, this is the flavor for you.
— Cookies and Cream — Classic and yummy (I would recommend more cookies, or another ice– cream with double or even triple the cookies)
— Oatmeal and Cookie — A nice blend of the ingredients in the name of the flavor with swirls of caramel.
P. S. I love the menu! So cool and the prices are affordable. There’s a covered deck where you can enjoy your tasty delights. I was told that this place is only open during the summer.

Allison is A+ behind the counter. She was awesome and someone who does a grey job pleasing the customer and being customer friendly. Highly recommend.

I had some vanilla soft serve. It was ok but a little too fake tasting. I know, I know, what do you expect for soft serve but some of it tastes pretty creamy.

For me the best thing is these guys have a decent selection of hard ices cream and you can get your shake made with hard ice cream compared to most places and the crap soft-​serve. But, I say «your shake» because they don’t have malted milk to make malts. Seriously? Come on, you’re an ice cream joint for heaven’ sake…

This is one of the best creameries I’ve been to upstate. Not in terms of the location or staff: strictly based on the ice cream. Unless something has changed since I’ve been back that is, as it has been awhile. It’s right beside Orange Plaza, with a large outdoor covered deck area for seating. Many of the girls working here are jail bait, so depending on your age that will be a bonus or a deterrent; when I was in high school I considered this a good thing, now maybe not as much. They can be a little headed too, but they work in an ice cream shop; they don’t exactly need a doctorate in filling up cones and cups.
Aside from that, like I said the ice cream is great! I usually get either vanilla, coockie dough, or cookies and cream. I haven’t had more than tastes of anything else, as I stick to my guns when it comes to ice cream. But everyone I’ve been here with – friend, foe, or family – also has already raved about the ice cream. It doesn’t need toppings at all either! The prices are about average for a place like this, and now that I’m thinking about it, I will go back soon!

best Ice cream that we have had in a long time and the prices are reasonable

If your 16, have a nose piercing and are willing to wear shorts short enough that your ass falls out, then you too could be a Frosty Rock Creamery Girl! I wouldn’t necessarily say that they are nasty (attitude wise), but they are definitely more interested in texting their friends than they are serving up Ice Cream. In either case, this is probably a shitty minimum wage job for them so I really can’t fault them. Anyway, you came here for Ice Cream not to meet some barely legal girls.
I’m not sure if others who reviewed this place came on a bad day, but the Ice Cream is top notch. I was always a fan of the black raspberry, it tastes homemade although I doubt it is. My sister turned me on to the cinnamon bun which is also very tasty. They have an outdoor deck with some picnic tables that has a beautiful view of the Planet Fitness Parking lot;-)

Overpriced and not that good. Went here once. There are much better options for ice cream in Middletown.