Jimmy P’s Pizzeria

Great pizza and excellent customer service. I’m very specific about how I like my pizza and they always make it exactly how I like it.
I also tend to hang out for a bit when I go. I watch a full game or use the Internet for awhile and they always are asking me if I need anything. When I go to jimmy’s I feel like I’m at my own home. Great pizza. Great staff

This is one of my favorite pizza places between Pizza Hut and pizza my heart. I enjoy it very much, but the lock on the front entrance appeared to be broken? How do they close up without any burglars breaking in? Was this here when Dutchman’s Pizza was still around? I rate four stars.

Went in since changing from Dutchman’s to Jimmy P’s and was impressed. Previously it smelled and wasn’t too impressed.
Seems they have cleaned it up and customer service was really good. They have a good beer selection and prices are reasonable.
The wife and I both liked the pizza and the hot wings were good. They were lightly dressed but I always ask for additional sauce on the side so no complaints at all.

First off customer service was really good (can’t complain) however I don’t see this place around to long. For one they squirt on the BBQ sauce for the wings and that’s that, I asked if they could put the wings in a plastic container and shake them to evenly spread the sauce. She stated that’s how we have to do it. 2^nd the pizza is dry and has no heart put into making it and it shows. Very light on sauce, toppings and cheese. For a 9.00 Stromboli they could add a little more sauce, presentation is nice however. I also think they should scale the price to 7.00, skip the chips if there worried about the margin reduction. I really hope this place can improve because the inside is really comfortable feeling and the staff is very friendly. Maybe I’ll make done in review.

Disappointing. spent a lot of money there but when the service is garbage again an again u don’t waste ur hard earned money. old white guy with glasses is a jerk. u wanna get treated like crap go to jimmy ps.

The other low star reviews are truthful.
It has more of a carry out feel to it. You order and then seat yourself with a pager. Pick up your pizza at the counter. Yes you will make multiple trips to counter to ask for plates or silverware. It’s basically a one (or maybe two) man operation. Service is non existent. Expect nothing.
The online menu and the menu on the counter gave three choices of sauce for wings. I ordered the spicy bbq. But the reality is they only have one sauce… Buffalo. And I wasn’t told that when I ordered. I would have appreciated being told that when I ordered spicy bbq.
Save your money. The $ 36 large pepperoni, mushroom, blk olive pizza tasted like a frozen DiGiorno. Crust seemed like it was pre-​frozen.
Deadly quiet environment. Sports on tv, but volume low (or off).

Beer selection is awesome. Pizza is great and my wife loves the potato skins. Every one I’ve given a slice of pizza to loved it. Problems maybe sometimes but their worth it.

Felt ripped off ! ordered a large, it came with almost two inches of
outer crust with NOTHING ON IT!
No toppings, nothing !!! a waste of $$ lost almost half the pizza on thick crust with ZERO
What I ordered topping on it. Why not place toppings all the way to the edge? Taste was O
K for a supreme but skimpy topping
Not going back

All you can eat Thursdays is the way to go. The pizza is good and I the have some good beers on tap. I haven’t tried the menu but if the pizza is any indication I will make this a usual pizza spot. The kids love it lots of games. I’ll be back

Good pizza, reasonable prices. All you can eat Thursday! Bring the kids. Great place and I will be coming back again!
Big screen tvs perfect for watching the game.
They also have lots of other options instead of pizza.
Also have good beer on tap! Thank you

Are they still in business? If they are, I’m surprised. What a horrid experience. Thank goodness we didn’t get sick.
It started with placing the order on the phone — she stated, «Hold on.» I could then hear her talking to someone, presumably an employee. «What do you mean you’re afraid?» «You have to tell me. I’m the boss.» After several words exchanged, comes back to the phone, takes my order and tells me when it will be ready.
I walked in to the place, only one family there waiting for their food. I stand at the counter. No one acknowledges my presence. There is a young man working at the back counter — wearing shorts, a t-​shirt, shoes with no socks and a baseball cap. To my right is a conveyor belt. It is not moving. There is a pizza sitting at the end of the conveyor and one pizza inside the stopped conveyor.
After a few minutes the young man sees me and says someone will be with me shortly. After several minutes a woman comes out of the back room. She states something vague about why she wasn’t at the counter, says my order will be ready soon. She fires up the conveyor belt.
As I wait, she calls the family up to receive the pizza that had been sitting at the end of the conveyor. A minute later, the family member comes up and asks for plates and flatware. She hands him a couple of plates. He asks for more plates and the flatware. She looks all over the kitchen, then goes in the back and comes out with a couple more plates. He asks for the flatware. She goes in the back again and comes out with a few pieces.
As I’m waiting, the décor gets older and dustier, the carpet more stained and ripped, the woman behind the counter keeps scratching her neck…
The pizza was skimpy, barely cooked ingredients, with wet dough. It was awful.
My advice to Jimmy P? Close your doors. You will never make it. You know nothing about food service, sanitation, nor product.

Why can’t Morgan Hill get a decent pizza place? I know, MOD is great, but it’s a chain and they don’t deliver. Tried this for the first time… tasted like frozen pizza. Margherita pizza actually had dried basil sprinkled on it. Dough was like cardboard. $ 25 for a large (which was really a medium)…expensive and just bad!

Nice service, tap beer selection, and loads of TV’s. Good place to watch sports. Pizza is the equivalent of a frozen pizza. They offer a few different sizes and that’s nice. Topping selection is good too. The pizza crust is absolutely nothing special, could have been frozen… We had a salad and that was just iceberg lettuce with a few cucumber slices and cherry tomatoes. Paper plates, and not the heavy duty ones, and the salad was on a melamine plate. They have a nice selection of video games for kids.

There is this pizza & it’s not on the menu & it’s a brainchild creation from the Cooking mind of Jenny & assistant Manager Angelica
It’s called the brick and it’s off the hook
If your watching your calories or are Gluten free allergic… this ain’t 4 U… grab a cold ass beer n check it out!

It is definitely an upgrade to Dutchmen’s. I mean, it could be a little better (higher quality ingredients and maybe more toppings) but it could also be MUCH worse. The green beans were good and it’s a great place to have a party! They do need to learn how to cut a pizza though. They don’t wait long enough to cut the pizza so the cheese melts back together and it is totally lame. Jimmy P, please wait 3 – 5 minutes after the pizza comes out of the oven before cutting it!

Upgrade from dutchmans! Love the wings and beer selection and a lovely staff!!! thanks for the love guys!

Pizza sucks. Tasted like a school cafeteria made it. Also tried the hot wings with some Italian sauce that was a disaster. I figured they take a decent pizza (formerly Dutchman’s Pizza) and make it better. It’s only gone downhill by cutting corners and having teenagers that don’t care have their run of the place. Take pride in your place Jimmy P. It has your name on it.

First time experience at Jimmy P’s was horrible. The service was slow and it wasn’t even busy. For the price the pizza wasn’t that great and the pizza fell apart when pulling the slices apart because they cut it horribly. Most likely never going back with all the other pizza options out there.

So far we haven’t been disappointed with Jimmy P’s, I had my husband’s birthday party there and everyone was happy with the service and especially with the pizza. This will be our go to Pizza place from now on.

I enjoyed JPs Morgan Hill Special. The crust was crunchy & the toppings made it soooo delicious. Veronica was a great hostess. Beer excellent too.
I definitely will spread the word… awesome to have a good pizza joint in town. It’s a keeper.

My wife and I walked in to see if any changes had been done, unfortunately the same old style blower air oven, I sure wish they would get a brick oven and cook pizzas like you’re supposed to be cooked and I will wait the extra 20 to 25 minutes, however with it still being the same old way my business is going to say no way.

Went there with my family. Amazing hot wings, pizzas were delicious and thin crust. The staff was so patient and sweet. And on Wednesdays pizzas are half price!

Nice staff. And they’ve really cleaned the place up. Pizza was average — need more toppings– but still thought it was better than dutchmens.

We got 2 pizzas to go from this place last night and would give them zero stars if we could. It was so bad where do I start…
1. The workers don’t wear gloves when preparing the food
2. They ran out of cheese (seriously)
3. The place was empty for a Friday night at 6:30 PM
4. There wasn’t enough toppings on either of our pizzas
5. Crusts were slightly under cooked and doughy
6. They forgot to put a topping (onions) on one of our pies and we caught them sprinkling them on uncooked at the last minute after the pizzas were sliced and boxed
7. Their large pizzas are on the smaller side, more like medium
The kids ate it because they don’t know any better, while we adults went back out to get MOD. We won’t be going back.

Went here the other night and the food was great, people are great and the facility is clean. I’m not a beer drinker but they have several beers on tap.
The only problem I had was that there wasn’t enough meat on our pizzas. I order the «JP’s Mexican» and «Gilroy Garlic Chicken». Both of the pizzas tasted great. Probably best pizza in town but if I’m going to spend $ 50.00 for two pizzas and only have a small amount of meat on the pizza. I would think there would be a good amount of meat on it especially when spending that much.
Hopefully they fix that issue because this place is really good.

Came here today and it was a hit. Thursday 5 – 8 buffet night. Awesome food, awesome atmosphere, awesome staff. Even a few games to keep the kids busy. Greta for family dinner or after a kids sporting event.

Family and I were hungry after Church and wanted to try the new pizza place in Morgan Hill. Great welcoming people excellent proportions and the food tasted great. If you’re hungry and have a large family are a bunch of friends for about 50 bucks get two pieces three sides to pictures of soda or drink which can normally do the job. Great job guys keep it up.