Theo’s Pizza

Delicious and a good price point!
We order from here a lot from the office. The pizza is delicious, the delivery time was reliable.
The price point is also worth looking at for large orders — we shopped around for best price for a tray of pasta with sauce and Theo’s was more affordable than even some supermarkets.

I wish I could say better things. But alas, no.
My husband and I live in Natick Center and like to try new places to eat, especially delivery because we have two little ones.
Theos was our try tonight — and will be our last. It took over an hour for delivery, which was ok. However, the delivery couldn’t find our house and asked me to stand outside in the cold while he found me. For over 10 minutes in the cold. And he hung up on me.
Ok so pizza made it. I wish I could say it was good, but honestly was just a step above frozen.

was doing laundry around the area so I got two slices for me and hubby and the pizza tasted really, really cheap, usually the cheese outweights the the pizza but, will never come here again!

Got some great sandwiches here. This is a great example of a family owned business. Jimmy the owner is a great cook!

It was my first time eating there.
Buffalo chicken tenders tasted like they had been sitting out for a while. Definitely wasn’t satisfied with my calzone:(

If I wanted to eat cold onion rings that taste like freezer burn then I could have gotten them out of my own freezer.

This is you’re typical (Greek style) mom n pop pizza shop.
We placed an order for 3 Large pizzas,
Theo’s special, chicken Alfredo and a plain cheese pizza.
The chicken Alfredo pizza was really really good and definitely not too bad for $ 15 but I was very sad with the Theo’s special pizza. For $ 17, I could tell right away that some of the toppings were processed or canned (mushrooms) and the veggies (peppers) were certainly not as fresh. The cheese pizza was like any other Greek style cheese pizza.
I can’t say anything about their subs as I haven’t tried them but this isn’t bad if you would like to pick up a quick pizza on the way home.
If I come back, I will only be going for the chicken Alfredo pizza.

The food I’ve had from Theo’s is good. It’s hot or cold enough when it should be. The salads are always very fresh. The portions are good size. I’ve ordered from there twice but each time someone else picked it up so I haven’t been inside. I do have to say that I was surprised the first time I called because the person taking my order was kind of abrupt and rushed. I figured we all have bad days. But the second time I ordered, it was clearly the same person, and he was down right rude and seemed totally impatient. I asked who it was and he said the owner. I don’t get treated that badly anywhere else I go in my daily life! He definitely shouldn’t be answering the phone. I hope if we order there again someone else picks it up again!

I started frequenting Theo’s a few months ago, after I gave up on Papa Gino’s because of uneven quality and poor service.
Now, just a few months later, I walk in and they greet me like a friend. If they are busy (which is often), they give me the food and trust me to pay just before I leave.
The pizza is great, the sandwiches and subs are a good portion size, and they offer lunch specials and a slice of the day.
The same people (family) are there every day. They work hard, and manage to smile, present good service, and produce great tasting food.

Stay clear of this place! The owner is very rude!!! I called to order a pizza & sub then… I told him how the pizza slid in the box and stuck to the top of the box, and he said «well, that happens you don’t come here anymore.» I said, «excuse me?» he said «you don’t come here anymore. go somewhere else.» I couldn’t believe it! Here was the owner of this place (I asked him if he was the manager. he said,” I“m the owner.”) treating his customer like garbage!
It’s very rude because when we ordered the pizza that slid and stuck to the top of the box, I called that night just to let them know. The guy on the phone that night said to mention it the next time we called to order something, and they would give us a discount!
So, this guy is just a dishonest, rude man!
He should be put out of business! And, my husband hates the greasy pizza. He’s happy that I won’t order from here anymore!

Pizza is actually pretty good if you like greek style. The other stuff was solid but nothing special.

I just signed up for Unilocal because I couldn’t believe some of the reviews for Theo’s. My fiancé and I order this pizza all the time and it is awesome. The Grecian Chicken Pizza with garlic is quite possibly the best pizza in the world. The inside is not sharpest joint, but if you want a good pizza it can’t be beat (except possibly by Pizzeria Regina (the real one in the North End)), and you can always order delivery.

This place ROCKS!
I think this is by far the best pizza house in the area. I order from here several times a week and it is always good and the service is always friendly.
I highly recommend the greek salad with grilled chicken. Yum. I grew up on «greek» style pizza so this place is as comforting as it gets.

Pizza is okay, though slices are are small, and rather greasy for my taste. This is definitely Greek style pizza.
The Chicken Parm subs are Luscious, and large.
Yesterday I got a Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap that would have been stellar, except that they hadn’t washed the lettuce well, and I ate a bunch of dirt along with the salad. A bit of a turn-​off, to be sure. Otherwise, it could have been perfect.

This place is just down the street from our office building. We get take-​out a lot for meetings, long days, etc and these guys already know us and our likes/​dislikes well just after a few orders. They must have caller ID because they know exactly who is calling. They know our salad preferences by heart and are not at all bothered by our picky substitutions and requests (extra cucumbers?). Love that!
Their salads are huge and the $ 5 — $ 6.50 prices are more than reasonable. Haven’t tried the pizza or subs yet, but we are already fans!
Too bad they don’t deliver.

SOLID, GUY.
Theo’s has been serving the students, faculty, and alumni of Wilson Middle School for years. A great Early Release Day spot! They serve other loyal patrons as well. No membership club dues needed here.
Buffalo chicken sub is a great choice. Good calzones too.