3 Brothers From Italy Pizza

I thought it was decent pizza… average. big slice, but it cost $ 3.75 for cheese. I like others on the boardwalk better… just average.

This place has the best pizza ever. I recommend the barbecue chicken. This place has huge slices but recently raised high prices of 5 $ a slice. But well worth it cause its amazing. Many people go to manco and manco, but there pizza is not good and the line is always so so long. Three Brothers is the place to go.

Absolutely amazing pizza. The crust was perfect and it had a great sauce. And the slices are HUGE. Be sure to try the white ricotta pie… amazing.

Amazing pizza!!! Had to stop every day we were in Ocean City and didn’t have a bad slice. Tried multiple toppings and they were all delicious.
Coming from Chicago, this pizza is awesome!

The pizza is good but I’ve seen employees smoking cigarettes in the kitchen multiple time. I’m not sure that I’ll go back there again.

Being from New York, I consider myself a pizza aficionado. YES its the water. NO your shitty new jersey water just doesn’t cut it.
Actually,
3 brothers from Italy pleasantly surprised me. It was a solid thin crust slice with a good sauce and good sauce/​cheese ratio. Its on the boardwalk so its expensive but its also the largest slice ive ever eaten. For the ambitious eater they will give you free pies if you can take down an entire pie by yourself.
Not sure if they pay for the ER visit when you have a heart attack.

HUGE slices. My wife and I split a slice of white pizza with ricotta and spinach. We asked if they could cut the slice in 2 so we could share and they did so, and gave us extra plates.
Hot thin crust. Not overly greasy. Just the right amount of toppings.
We found the staff to be funny and friendly. Prices were about what we expected for Boardwalk pizza.

I love pizza. Love it, love it, love it. I especially love pizza at the shore. This was my first time ever trying 3 Bros pizza. I always thought the price per slice was a bit too much. Since their closest competitor had a line out the door and my family was «starving», we went to 3 Bros (much to my reluctance). Their staff was so sweet (service always is a plus to me). Yes, the per slice price is a lot. Now you need to LOOK at the slice you get. The thing is mammoth! There pizza’s are 26″ in diameter. Do your math, folks. That’s a BIG slice, equal to practically two slices of regular size pizza. After doing my own math (I’m a numbers person by trade), 3 Bros gives you some bang for your buck! AND IT’S GOOD! So there you have it. Good pizza with a price that’s is a bit high yet deceiving since you get more than you think.

Best pizza on the boardwalk hands-​down. The staff is a bit rude, while some of its members are truly funny characters. Other than this, this place does an amazing job and always amazes me.

I was sooo looking forward to a classic boardwalk slice at 3 bros, but man did they disappoint! First off the regular slice was not that tasty. It was SUPER thin with barely any sauce. I ended up ordering the bbq chicken because I really didn’t like the plain slice, that one was just meh. Also the reason this place is definitely getting one star is they charge for tap water… uh c’mon now!

Great pizza & great service on the boardwalk! The place is small… but that’s what we expected being on the boardwalk. They accommodated the 6 of us & our waitress was more that nice. We got a whole pie & everyone (kids & adults) loved it! We’ll be back!

My favorite pizza in OC, huge slices. no need to get a whole pie unless your a big group or really hungry. I don’t mind price when it’s good pizza, Manco Manco is overrated, go here instead

Awesome place to go when in OC. This is my idea of what boardwalk pizza is. The slices are large, the crust is thing, and the sauce is more on the sweet side which I like. Seating is very tight but I would recommend stopping by.

Everytime my boyfriend and I come to ocean city, we stop in here and surprisingly we’ve never had the pizza. I usually get the philly cheese steak and he gets the chicken parm hero. Good reviews on the pizza so I guess we should try it sometime: P
You can sit on your own or a waitress can come take your order. No outside drinks. Nice people behind the counter. See you when we come back to OC!

3 Brothers is my go-​to pizza place on the boardwalk because even though each slice is about $ 5, the size of the slice is closer to the equivalent of two pieces of pizza at almost any other pizza establishment. Absolutely enormous– probably as long as my arm. I’m always full after eating a piece. Go for the specialty pizza, especially the buffalo chicken pizza. It’s really yummy and just tangy enough without making you super-​thirsty. Plus, they shred the chicken over the top instead of leaving it in strips.

Huge slices but a little pricey… Still amazing though! My husband wants to try the challenger!

To me the whole Manco and Manco thing is a tad overrated. Yes, it is good pizza. No doubt about that, but 3 Brothers in my opinion tops it as best of the OC boardwalk. Their specialty pizza is really where they shine. I can’t walk in and not get their buffalo chicken pizza. All their pizza crusts are nice and crispy and their toppings are fresh. You are doing yourself a disservice if you don’t at least give it a try. The pricing is on the higher side, but that is because the slices are absolutely enormous. My girlfriend and I split a slice for $ 5 and were pleasantly filled (but we had just gorged on Curley’s Fries earlier). The service is SUPER friendly and the waitress brought us out some waters without even asking. Full array of pizza condiments at the table for those who love to doctor it up a bit. They do accept credit card here which is nice.

When I’m on the Boardwalk, I want great pizza and this is the place to get it. Huge slices are a bit pricey, but 2 paper plates can’t contain this pizza! Sauce is good, not sweet. Crust is just the right thickness and plenty of cheese. They also have fresh cut fries that are awesome as well! You can’t go wrong! If you’re on the Boardwalk in OC, give it a try!

I definitely agree with the previous reviewer who said this is the second best pizza on the boards after Manco’s. The slices are gigantic but don’t get floppy and gross like some big pizzas can. I’ve had plain, BBQ, and buffalo and they are all great, with buffalo being my personal favorite.
If you’re looking for a $ 0.99 slice, however, this is not the place! A slice here will set you back about $ 5, with a whole pie coming in around $ 30. But if you can eat a whole gigantic pizza in 15 minutes you get 250 free pizzas or something like that.

HUGE slices of pizza!!!
Personally, when I go to the shore and hit the boardwalk and am craving some pizza, I just want a traditional thin crust pizza. Nothing fancy just good honest to goodness Italian traditional pizza. This place hits the spot for me. $ 5 a slice but its basically 2 slices in one.
Bottom line; If you like dropping $ 3.75 a slice on overrated pizza just because they use a «hose» to pump their tomato sauce on, then you know where you can go. If you want REAL Italian pizza, go to 3 brothers.