Papa John’s Pizza

Love the steak sammie try it never disappoints. Also check out their classes they offer many at different times of the year. I really want to try one of the «Breaking all the Rules» dinners that have wine pairings I’ve only heard great things about those.

I don’t know about saying this is the «best pizza in town» but I was satisfied. Honestly, the lack of the fifth star is mostly due to my experience using their online ordering.
I didn’t feel as if ordering online was a smooth experience. Especially if wanting to use one of their current deals/​coupons and then adding any sides or extras that aren’t included in the deal. Once you pick the item (s) you want with a deal, it takes you straight to checkout and it was somewhat difficult to navigate. I also wanted to add jalapeños to my pizza but after 10 min of trying to figure out how to do that online, I decided to NOT spice it up. That’s all for my explanation of not giving the fifth star.
Once I ordered my pizza was delivered in 30 – 35 minutes. The gentleman who delivered it was very polite and friendly, even thanking me (very sincerely) for his tip. He also brought me some plates, napkins, crushed red pepper and parmesan cheese which was a great surprise! They also included a cup of their garlic dipping sauce with the pizza which was yet another pleasant surprise!
The pizza was exactly what I would expect from a «fast pizza restaurant» chain. Again, perhaps not the best in town, but the best when compared to similar pizza chains

Great pizza. Great staff. Great price. App is easy to use. I order pizza at Home and at my office. Pizza is always consistently delicious. Wings are good too.

This is my favorite pizza in town. The ingredients are fresh and the dough is how I like it. Not too thick… not too thin… just right. I usually order online for carryout. Seems they are always pulling it right out of the oven just as I am walking in… so it’s hot and fresh. And the garlic dipping sauce is the best! The Gage location that I go to is always spotless and the service is excellent.

We order a lot of pizza in our family, and we like to switch back and forth with Papa Johns, Dominos, and Pizza Hut. When I’m looking for the healthiest and most loaded pizza, I go to Papa Johns. I really enjoy their marketing through social media as well, and I always look at their local facebook page before ordering, as they offer a lot of specials. We’ve never had a problem with the Gage location, the delivery is always fast and all our orders have been correct. Only recommendation I’d say is a little more sauce would be nice, but sometimes less sauce is a good thing!

Great Pizza, and awesome customer service! They are fast in making the pizza, have never had any problem and unfortunately know us by name :)
Love there interaction with their fans on Facebook! Posted a silly photo of one of my pizzas not getting cut, and had comment back within 30 min! They impress me.

I’m a PJs fan normally but this location sucks. I had to call twice to get someone to answer the phone. When I went to pick it up, they guy acted like I was inconveniencing him. Oh and the order was wrong. Suck at your job somewhere else please.

Disappointing. I’ve normally been a big fan of Papa John’s but compared to Domino’s and Pizza Hut’s current offerings it’s not even close. The pizza is very bland, the marinara sauce is watery and the cheesy bread is basically pizza. Too Bad!

Nice new storefront in a (unfortunately) twice failed pizza location. Gage is a tricky street. There’s enough traffic, but the nearby demographic is finicky. I will say that Papa Johns probably has the best chance (of the three pizza joints that have occupied this space) of success due to name branding and a nice store front. The staff was nice and helpful. I had made my order online and called in to confirm. My pizza was coming out the oven as we spoke (very quick turn around!). Granted this was around 9:30pm on a Monday (you don’t judge me), so order traffic was light. I will say that the online service is a pinch tricky. Check your junk mail box for the confirmation email after you order! If you have ordered at a Papa John’s before, this is consistant with their style. A light floury crust and tasty cheese. Boxed with a pickled pepper and the guilt-​inducing garlic butter dipping sauce. I prefer Papa John’s over most chain pizza joints (save for probably Round Table) because the pizza doesn’t feel as greasy and the ingredients seem to be at a higher quality.