Topper’s Pizza

Was staying at the Country Inn and had delivery, it was great pizza, we had the taco beard sticks pizza also and it was delicious.

Not gonna lie, I love me some Topper’s! They tend to be conveniently located on college campuses, so it’s a stretch for us to come down to College Ave just for pizza. If we are in the area, it is our #1 choice for franchise pizza.
Triple order of Tacostix and whatever specialty pizza that catches the eye that day for the win!

Doesn’t deliver to addresses on the same street in which it’s located on. Customer service is non-​existent. Pizza is average and the prices are way too high. No real reason to go here as there are many surrounding pizza places that excel in the areas that Toppers fails in.

Toppers, Toppers, Toppers. Apparently this is *the* place to get your late-​night pizza fix for local Lawrence University students. I’ve eaten here a few times and here are my to-​the-​point impressions.
Likes:
–Regular Topperstix. These are the shining star of this place! Don’t fool yourself into thinking a single order can be shared. Always go for that triple order. I haven’t tried the other options (bacon, cinnamon, etc) because the regular are that good.
–Deals. With a little research, you can find some kind of deal going on here. The last time I went, there was a one-​topping large pizza + single order Topperstix deal for only $ 15. A good deal! We stuffed our faces and still had leftovers.
Meh (because I don’t truly ‘dislike’ anything about Toppers):
–Pizza. It’s just okay. I’m from Chicago and I have had so much better. Unless you’re using a deal, I would recommend skipping the pizza and just sticking to the sinfully delicious Topperstix.
–Generally, the food is better as leftovers heated up in the oven the next day. Then, the pizza has some great crisp to it.
Will I be back? I’m sure I will be the next time I happen to be in the little apple.

First this review is for the new Menasha location on 3^rd st.
I was excited to have my wife try a Toppers pizza, now i regret it. We ordered 2 medium pizzas and the original topperstix at 5:05PM (12/​12/​2014) and was told by Andrew that our order would be there in 20 – 30 minutes. At 6:15pm I called to check if the driver got lost, Andrew told me they were running behind on deliveries, at 6:35 pm the pizza finally arrived. after being an hour late, ALL ITEMS had raw dough! Completely unacceptable! I had to feed my 3 yr olds something else instead of the pizza they were looking forward to.
I called back to Toppers and asked for the manager and Andrew indicated he could assist me. I offered my feedback and he said, «sorry» but failed to offer me a refund on my order as stated on their box (another fail on Toppers).
But the delivery driver did offer me a coupon for 50% 0ff my next order, big help that is for a pizza I will NEVER order!
Given the other feedback here don’t waste your money ordering here.

My husband has lived in Appleton his whole life and has been ordering (and TIPPING well) for years. It’s the 1^st place he recommended when I moved in with him in 2010. We ordered often, but recently had a Mexican-​style pizza delivered to our home that had raw pizza dough and fell apart as we picked up a slice. There was hardly any good toppings on it, but a load of tortilla chips slopped over the whole pizza. My husband wrote a complaint and received no response or apology from the company. I called about a month later to ask them to take us off their mailing list (I truly didn’t want any advertisements from them). The manager (I believe her name was Michelle) asked for a reason so I told her our experience. She took our names and phone # down and promised to get back to us. The company never did. Never stepping foot in this place again. If this is the way they do business, by not taking their loyal customers seriously, then they are slowly going to lose them throughout the years. Any good business owner knows the golden rule of business… that it’s harder to make new customers than it is to keep the old ones. We were pretty offended by how we were treated/​disregarded. We are now very loyal fans of the Glass Nickel Pizza Co., and I’m sure they’re enjoying our very generous tips too.

A couple of good things on the menu can’t overcome the sheer lack of customer service. Unfortunately, it’s not just the local establishment but the cooperation itself as online complaints have been as fruitful as local complaints. I do not plan on giving this establishment or any others in the chain a single additional penny after years of loyalty. If you have to eat here order the topperstix or the hangover helper, but everything else on the menu is done better at other pizzerias within walking distance!

Toppers is open until 3 AM, so you can imagine the clientele who depend on this joint to satisfy late night munchies. Any person who lives in Appleton or maybe who has experienced its nightlife can tell you about Toppers!
Whether I’m out on the Ave. with friends or I’m having a late night in my dorm room with a term paper, Toppers is the place to go (or order). So maybe the pizza isn’t amazing quality or anything, but it fills you up and really satisfies you. The thing with that pizza, too, is that it is pretty much impossible to eat just one piece. Once I ate four pieces like it was nothing! What I completely CRAVE, though, are the Topperstix. Every time I’m back in Appleton, I have to include Topperstix into my plan somehow.
Just for fun: My favorite Toppers memory is when Barack Obama first won the election in 2008 and Toppers had $ 3 that night. A bunch of friends and I walked over there late at night, each picked up a big ol’ pizza, and walked down College Ave carrying our boxes. I don’t think I’ve ever eaten more pizza in one night!
Tip: A lot of time there are coupons, so always ask if there is a special when placing your order. I have gotten some incredible deals that way! Also, there are only two tables, so don’t necessarily count on eating there.

My buddy Paul says it’s super heady dank munch. Just don’t take too many wiskey shots before you get here, you’ll be hurt in your sleep.

I’ve never had the pizza and that is because you should never order anything at Toppers other than the world famous Topperstix. Easily in my top 5 favorite foods. They are cheesy, garlic, dough pillows from heaven. You’re welcome!!!

Topper’s has great specialty pizzas. I especially like the Tuscan Chicken pizza. The sun dried tomatoes, feta cheese, and fresh basil will send your taste buds dancing!

Let me preface this review by saying I’m a little tipsy. A few beers over at Jim’s Place (an upcoming Unilocal). But I was compelled to remove my laptop from it’s TSA-​approved carrying case to connect to the Hotel wifi to Unilocal about Topper’s pizza as soon as I coudl.
It’s that good.
Food is a must after a few beers and this place was open until 3AM so PERFECT. We ordered a 16″ (medium) pizza and they let you order half-n-half’s. We got a half-​Taco and half-​buffalo pizza (thanks to the dude behind the counter for the buffalo pizza suggestion). AND DUDE, IT’S AMAZING! The taco pizza half was loaded with seasoned ground beef, tcheddar cheese, lettuce, tortilla strips, tomatoes, and olives. Picked out the olives, gross. The buffalo half featured with perfectly sized chicken bits and smothered in a delicious buffalo sauce. And it was so good. Despit the olives. And without even asking, they included ranch. bleu cheese, salsa AND sour cream with the ordre without having to request it. Friendly staff who asked if we needed plates, and all of the other accoutrements that I cannot remember.
The facility was clean & inviting too.
I was only planning on eating one slice but I’ve had 4, one of which I’m enjoying as I type. I’ll have to clean the cheese and salsa from my laptop keyboard tomorrow morning!