Blue Moon Pizza

Very poor service and food is not good compared to the price they charge. Pizza was not made properly. And the waitress was very unpolite.

The friendliest service ever! Please try the wraps and the chicken parm is to die for!!! This gentleman is really involved in the community and truly wants his pizza shop to be the best in Cape May! He’ll have no trouble!

Saw one of the employees take a slice off display bring it into the back only to return with it and put it back a minute later. Why did the slice need to go in the back? I guess they don’t like their pizza either. Weird they own a Quiznos oven.

My family and I love this place!!! It’s only a short walk from the beach: extra convenient.
The pizza is amazing and it usually is not too crowded. The workers are OK, they have never bothered us but have never made attempts to be extra nice or friendly to customers.
All in all, the pizza at blue moon is really good, and I would recommend it to everyone looking for a quick bite!

I specifically asked for a pizza with no Cheese on it since we are all vegans. I mentioned it like 3 times and he said he understood it. And they delivered a pizza with loads of cheese on it.
Not happy

Asked for a extra cheese pizza and they brought me a meat lovers pizza. When we told delivery guy they made a mistake he yelled at us and said we got what we ordered. Definitely do not recommend. Overpriced and very rude.

Extremely poor service there was no one else in there besides my family and it took very long the food was … .mediocre at best… to top it off they started painting the eating area while we were sitting there! We abdoned our food and had to leave I’m not about to sit and inhale paint fumes with my 2 yo and newborn.

Blue Moon Pizza is another Cape May standard. They are one of the two pizza joins I do try to frequent yearly. Trust in their pizza as the slices are usually fresh and the customer service has always been pleasant. Perfect spot to grab a slice after the sun goes down!

Horrible pizza poorly cooked. Tastes like it has sat out all day. Reheated in a Quiznos over and they ran it through twice. It was crispy/​burnt and tastes over cooked.
Also pizza was almost $ 4 for a slice of pizza! That’s crazy. Pepperoni was Burnt

After a particularly boozy wedding reception, we made the wise choice to leave the after-​party a bit early in search of some alcohol-​soaking carbs. Someone working the front desk at our hotel recommended Blue Moon for delivery, and our pepperoni pie was delivered to our room in a very timely manner. From what my hazy memory recalls, it was adequate enough for me to scarf down three (or was it four?!) slices. Gotta love any place that delivers your late night drunken munchies fix!

This place is ooo too conveniently located next to Carneys and Cabanas. It’s almost hard to not stop in here on your way home from the bars.
The pizza is by the slice and they have everything from veggie to bakes ziti pizza! The service is fast and and the drunken characters are great entertainment. You are almost guaranteed to see at least one drunken heart to heart or make out.
I can’t think of a better way to end the night.

My friend and I came into town around 11pm and were looking for some good food. The only places open were a few bars that were over crowded. 5 places later with nothing to show, we ended up at this pizza place and were greeted by two people. We each got a couple of slices and soda. I got the cheese steak pizza and plain cheese. They were hot and yummy. It did the job. It reminds me of boardwalk pizza, meets neighborhood pizzeria.
Thank you again for being open late!!!

Get rid of your old conveyer belt oven– late night pizza was cold! Go to Louie’s down the street!

I was extremely hungry and visited this place hoping for some good pizza. I ordered a few slices, and they were not hot at all. The cheese slices tasted pretty good, but the Pepperoni tasted pretty nasty. If it were hot, that may have helped, but it was still a pretty nasty pepperoni. I’m not sure if it’s a cheap brand they use, or just old, but I wouldn’t get the pepperoni.
Ambiance inside is typical. It’s a little on the grungy side.

Well if you feel like paying over $ 40 for 2 pizzas go for it but Tony’s will charge you almost twice less and they were in business for over 20 years and this is a sign

I went there very recently and had fantastic pizza! My friend and I shared a slice of spinach pizza and a slice of tomato. Oh yes it was sooooo good! There really is only one good seat in the place and that’s in the window but good luck getting it. Then again, I didn’t go there for the atmosphere… or the sandy seats.

After a few days of watching the Blue Moon Pizza delivery car drive by our house, we decided to order pizza. Their menu was great– it had a huge selection of white pizzas, which is the preferred pizza of both me and my sister. Around 6pm we called for take out, and ordered 3 large pizzas– barbeque chicken white pizza, florentine white pizza (without the spinach, since they didn’t have plain white pizza on their menu), and regular pizza with pepperoni and onion. They told us the order would be ready in 35 minutes.
My optimistic brother-​in-​law decided it couldn’t possibly take 35 minutes to fulfill our order, and headed over after about 20 minutes. He was right– our order was ready. He said the cashier didn’t speak English that well, but he picked up the order with no issues.
The pizza was hot and tasty– I loved the crust. They put spinach on half of the white pizza, which was the only mistake on our order, but we sucked it up and ate it anyway (wasn’t bad!). The chicken BBQ pizza was quite good too. Three large pizzas will probably last the 5 of us for a dinner and 2 – 3 lunches. (They also had an XL pizza on their menu, which must be quite huge!). If you’re in Cape May and feeling like a pizza night, give Blue Moon a try!

We ate here because it was the only place open late (ish) at night. Just from looking, you can tell the pizza will be bad. And it is. It’s too thick, dry yet gloppy. Just terrible. Make sure you get dinner before 10pm so you are not stuck eating here.

Delivery guy didn’t know where we were staying… Two blocks from Blue Moon Pizza which I thought was weird. Pizza showed up cold, hard, over cooked and over priced. $ 25 for one lg pizza is a little crazy when is bairly edible.
I have them a D– circled in red pen like my 2^nd grade English teacher use to to.

Ask me how this pizza was three years ago, and I would have said DELICIOUS… but since that time… Blue Moon has changed for the worse. The last cheese pie i had was sloppy with little cheese and a sauce that would have been more suited as an ice cream topping (way too sweet). If you’re looking for a good pizza in Cape May, your best bet would be to go to Tony’s… if not there then Stumpo’s in the Wahington Mall makes a good pie, but it’s expensive and quite small.
One good point about Blue Moon though, is that it delivers everywhere, and at late hours on weekends.