Slice Of Edgartown

Dont listen to the jerks. The service is great, pies are tasty, staff is awesome, and unless you are a pretentious New Yorker, you’ll enjoy a slice of Edgardtown.

Got three pies (two cheese and one pepperoni) here last night and my stomach still hurts. They claim to have «Authentic NY style» pizza and that should have been warning enough… rarely does an advertisement like that get backed up. The pizza is most likely from frozen, as I don’t see an oven in sight. They prepare them in back, which I don’t think there is one pizza place in the actual state of NY that hides their pizza making process.
To the pies: the best comparison would be to bowling alley pizza. The dark burn spots on top of the cheese, the precut slices, lack of any real flavor. My family and I looked around at each other as we ate and knew instantly that this pizza was garbage.
Nearly 18 hours later, 4 out of 8 of us still have stomach aches. Never will I get pizza from this place again. I’d rather skip a meal.
Great location close to the town docks, though.

Love this little place!!! Great late night pizza. By the slice or be a fatty and get a family size pie. Friendly staff, cute walk up shop front with a bit of seating if you’re hungry then and there. Otherwise just walk down to the waterfront and eat it there.

Surprisingly good pizza for a small, mainly takeout, place. The pizza is New York style, with a thin chewy crust, which is a rare find in Massachusetts.

I love this place! The pizza is awesome! Crust is nice and chewy, sauce is full of flavor, and the cheese is fresh. Loved that is was walking distance to fun attractions. Hope it’s still around next time I get back to The Vineyard.

I am so excited to finally have GOOD pizza in Edgartown. My family just returned from our two week stay at the Harbor View, and we got both slices and pies at Slice of Edg. at least 4 times. Every time, the pizza was delicious and the service was great. It was very busy over the 4^th of July (to be expected when the parade and fireworks go off right outside their doorstep), so the wait was obviously long that night, but aside from that, I’ve never had to wait. So convenient to call in an order and literally do a «drive-​by» of the window to grab it. Cute brick patio area with a few tables, right in the heart of downtown… give it a try, you will be glad you did.

I rarely go out for pizza on the island, but sometimes it seems like a nice change of pace. S of E describes itself as New York-​style pizza, but it certainly isn’t, unless by «NY style» you mean «Domino’s style.»
You know the kind of pizza that has gobs of rubbery cheese on it that comes off when you take a bite, thus leaving behind a doughy, gummy, cheeseless glop? Do you like that kind? Neither do I. Way too much cheese, barely noticeable tomato sauce, unpleasantly chewy crust. I always eat my crust, but not on this bad boy. Oh, and I overheard that they were running 90 minutes on whole pies after I got my order.
Little kids might like it, or people desperate to have a night off from seafood, but I don’t see how anyone else could.
The only thing Slice has going for it is that it’s one of the only pizza places in town.

This new pizza restaurant is very new and very hard to find (it’s next to the parking lot in front of the Kelley House Hotel) in Edgartown.
However, the pizza is delicious and worth looking for!