A Bronx Tale Pizzeria

Horrible pizza. Worst I ever had! We couldn’t even eat it. The chicken Philly was bad as well. Very disappointed.

Terrible service! I ordered a pizza an hour before they closed they said they would deliver and never showed up. This is the second time they have done this. I’ll just eat from Napolis pizza in lake worth from now on. It’s better anyways.

We went here expecting maybe some NY kind of pizza and good expectations. The service here was repulsive. They overcharged us for some terrible pizza that they made when we got there even though we preordered through the phone. They also tried to charge us almost 5 dollars for one pepperoni roll that costs more than their regular slice with toppings. Afterwards they tried to say our payment didn’t go through when the charge was clearly reflected on my bank account. Terrible food and definitely overpriced. Came here visiting from NY and was extremely disappointed. Asked for buffalo pizza and got cut up chicken tenders with some hot sauce on the pizza. It was terrible. Do not recommended it at all.

It looks like the menu hey have photos of on here are a little bit off compared the prices listed if u go to place an order online. Like the anti pasta salad was 9 for the small when I ordered online. But the photo says its 9 $ for the large. Also, the toppings. It says meatballs are only like $ 1.75 extra but when I ordered it was almost $ 2.50 per topping! I got meatball and spinach. So not sure about that. Hopefully the taste is amazing and worth it Hahahah

They would get a 5 star (for a Florida restaurant) if they had whole wheat crust.

We have tried many pizza places in our area. The whole family actually agrees very good pizza!

Just had my wedding reception on April 24^th catered by A Bronx Tale Pizzeria and it was just fabulous!!! The food was delicious!!! Could not have been any better! So happy and beyond pleased! Everybody there just raved about the food!
Thank you so much for making my day even better with the amazing food!!!

So I now have a new addiction the honey garlic wings and blue cheese is off the charts. I’m talking enough for me to get a to go order and forced me to get on here and right the review. Hope in the wall kinda join with food network abilities! The balsamic for the salad is unreal too mind you I haven’t even got my main dish yet the chicken Marsala but I think I already know how it will be… UNREAL

Had the meat lovers pizza. Being from NY, I’m totally bias, however, I will admit to good pizza when I have it. Unfortunately, Bronx tale pizza isn’t the best. Sauce is oddly similar to dominos. Wouldn’t order it again.

Being from Brooklyn and eating pizza at the best spots, L&B’s, Totonno’s, Patsy’s, I consider myself a certified pizza snob, Bronx tale is the first pizza place I’ve eaten at in SoFlo that you can actually «snap» the slice in half… the way it’s supposed to be eaten. That’s says a lot. The crust is perfectly cooked and crisp. Staff and chef were so nice and accommodating. We ordered 3 salads, all 3 dressings were homemade & very delicious. The Chicken Francese was a little lemony for my taste but perfectly cooked, tender and fresh. If you like baked ziti, order it with meat sauce — it’s huge and simply amazing! Zeppoles were served with… lemon wedges? So yummy!

This pizza is so good and definitely authentic up north pizza! I ordered twice from them in a week and both times were stellar! Mondays they have a special for a large pie is only $ 10.99

This place has ruined me for pizza. I can’t eat anyone else’s pizza or tiramisu because no one else even comes close! You can taste the love each dish is made with and the sheer happiness of the employees is infectious. Thanks guys! — love, the couple down the road who always orders the sautéd mushroom pizza with your tiramisu to go!

I don’t live in this area but ordered the chx parm and very good size portion… thick cut cutlet and homemade sauce… it’s a «Bronx tale» for sure !

These guys had a rough night tonight they were down a chef in the kitchen and there was a tornado in florida today and I imagine most of there business is delivered but there food is great if I lived here I would eat this every day I was staying at the hotel located 500ft away. I ordered delevery an hour and 20 min later I just walked over and there were other customers impatiently waiting. But the chef/​manager was super friendly polite and apologetic and the whole staff kept there cool really well while being berated by hungry peopple. By the time I got and finished my meal they were back to running like a well oiled machine. If your anywhere near this place check it out its worth it. I found out later the head chef is the owner and he rocks Italian food like a good fella classic.

A Bronx Tale was a pretty sad pizzeria inside. Zero customers and cheesy décor was not welcoming to walk in to. Another thing that irked me was that they raised their prices on pizza three dollars but the quality has gone down. A little unfortunate also that the margarita pie didn’t have the fresh mozzarella they advertised. Definitely underwhelming for a nearly 25 $ pie. I won’t be returning.

Update time! Still a Fan of their slices. Their prices have gone up a little but not to bad. Before i had not visited and well now I finally visited their location, quite a few times. It reminds me of a true NY pizzeria.
Last i checked they were switching around their tables and chairs because the booths they had were quite beaten up. Small pizzeria in a plaza in lantana but still real good!
Other than the pizza, their Garlic Rolls are amazing as is their lasagna.
For their toppings I recommend the Fresh garden and margarita slices for something different but amazing.

The pizza is just like any decent pizza place. Yes better than papa johns but about the same as Sals. However it is way more expensive here. Their menu says 18 $ for a large signature pizza but they charged us 22 $. We bought 2 pizzas so that comes out to 8 $ over charged for pizza. Also we had gotten delivery the time before and it took over an hour to get delivered. We were offered our next pizza for free when we went there again. This time I go in and tell them I was offered a free pizza and they didn’t give it to me. I feel like if I’m inconvenienced and offered a free item it’s kinda rude to be like «nope just kidding we were just saying that.» This is not a very nice place.

After a long day of work, the roommate and I decided to just grab some pizza for dinner. He had been convinced that another pizza place had the best pies, so of course I had to prove him wrong. We called in an order for delivery (which was a struggle, we were told that we sounded like we were under water???), asked for pepper and cheese, and specifically stated that we only had 2 $ 20s so they should bring change. 30min later, we get our food, but no pepper, cheese, or change. The delivery guy was extremely courteous and offered to drive back to get change (no one had told him to bring extra), but we insisted that he call and ask if we could pay with card. Whoever picked up couldn’t understand what he was saying and thought it was another customer calling to place an order. After we got that whole fiasco figured out, we were finally able to enjoy the pizza and garlic rolls.
We got The Works and, like last time, it was loaded with toppings — pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, olives. The mushrooms were chunky so you could actually taste them, and the onions were caramelized and extra flavorful. Every bite was delicious and trumps any other Works pizza I’ve had. The garlic rolls were slightly better this time around, but they still haven’t quite figured out a good bread to garlic ratio. Only the top ¹⁄₃ gets the flavor, while the bottom ²⁄₃ is straight up bread.
Overall, the pizza is still great, but the garlic rolls are just meh and you might have some trouble placing an order over the phone.

Pizza is good but nothing special about the it though. got the chicken margerita and meatballs with ricotta. Cooked well crispy crust.
Long wait to get it though. The place is very popular and very busy. Some people love it but it’s just another place to me.
Staff is not very friendly, sorta like to pretend they are the pizza gestapo

I tried A Bronx Tale on a Sunday night with a friend and his wife. They were doing brisk business despite it being the closing hour (open until 10), which is almost always a good sign. We ordered an extra large pepperoni between us, which was 18 inches.
We were brought complimentary garlic rolls which was a nice touch. We all enjoyed the rolls, which were pretty good, crisp yet seemed to melt in your mouth after a few bites.
The pizza was cooked perfectly, and true to style with a nice thin crust. Good quality ingredients. I liked their pepperoni in particular and they didn’t skimp on it either. Their sauce is a touch on the sweeter side but not overpoweringly so. Good cheese and crust.
Service was good, only one minor mistake when they thought we were taking out instead of dining in but was quickly corrected. The staff was pleasant.
The place itself is smallish, in a not-​so-​great plaza, but as are most of the good local pizza places it seems. I thought it looked reasonably clean inside.
Overall we each thought that this was pretty good NYC style pizza and compared favorably with other PBC pizza joints. I would definitely return to Bronx Tale.