The Crafty Crust

My wife and I stopped in over the weekend. We didn’t come here in the evening because the previous reviews mentioned how small the seating was. After our visit it makes perfect sense. The place is small but the pizza is very good. We had the carnivore and it was very good. The young lady behind the bar was the bartender and waitress rolled into one. She hustled and was very out-​going. The beer selection is strong for such a small foot print of a space. We’ll definitely return… we just may sit at the bar and enjoy the fine beers until we get hungry.
A welcome addition to the area.

Arrived at 5:30pm and were listed as the first people on the wait list. We decided to wait and it ended up being a hour and 10 minutes. The hostess is also the waitress is also the bus boy is also the bartender… totally unorganized! We finally sit down ready to order right away because we could foresee it being a while! We went to place our order and we were told there was no more gluten free pizza!!! WHAT! When people in the party can only have gluten free pizza and waited just because this restaurant serves it you better believe we were totally disappointed! With that we left! No pizza. All that wait for nothing but a headache. I imagine the pizza must be good based on the amount of people waiting (none of whom were told how long the estimated wait would be). All I know is we were told take out would be at least 1.5 hours! Overall, huge disappointment, waste of time, and will not be going back. There’s many other amazing pies out there. In fact, after that debacle it’s probably easier to hop a flight and get a great pie in NYC! Do yourself a favor and hit up Tequesta Brewery for a tasty ipa and find yourself a pie anywhere else in the area!

Great for take out, but it does get crowded eating in. The meatball subs, pizza, soups, and house salads are amazing! They don’t always have soup, but when they do it’s good!

If you are ever in the Tequesta/​Jupiter area this is by far the best Pizza in town! Crust is to die for and everything else is just perfect, sauce is delicious!!!
They are very friendly and we always get great service.
They have an amazing lunch special for 2 slices of pizza and a drink for under $ 5 bucks! The only downside is that they now only open for lunch on Friday and the weekend. I am not sure however if they have that lunch special on the weekend?
Regardless the prices are fair and the pizza is delicious. I got their wings once and they were really great as well.
They have a large selection of Beers.
Just a friendly small neighborhood Pizza joint with really delicious, fresh Pizza!

Got take out from here with great expectations. Was very disappointed. Seemed like some of the slices lacked cheese. Very soggy and not hot. I would probably go somewhere else next time.

Love this place … food is great. Libations are generous. & the host & staff are terrific

Popped in here for lunch today while shopping in the plaza… We ordered a small pizza with meatballs and carmelized onions. It was tasty but could have used more onions — they are cheap so load it up. My daughter ordered wings and said they were ok. They have a good selection of beers but unfortunately I don’t drink when driving my kid in the middle of the day. I may go back but honestly for brick oven pizza I can go to many places nearby… There was nothing special about this place

I can’t believe I never noticed this place before! I frequent the plaza that’s it’s located in all the time. Very small local spot that’s easy to overlook if you’re not looking for it. They have a great selection of craft beer, and fresh pizza, plus very friendly service

Delicious Pizza, service was superb. The Brew wasn’t so shabby either, I’ll be back !!!

I went here on a Sunday night for dinner. It was packed with people. We put our name on the waiting list then decided we would get to go since we weren’t sure how long the wait would be. But right after we did that, some people left the bar area which is open seating so we grabbed seats there after having waited 15 – 20 min. We decided we would eat there. My friend tried one of the beers on tap. The bartender was really helpful in selecting beers. She could tell you everything about each of them and would give you a sample if you weren’t sure which one you wanted. We ended up ordering buffalo chicken wings as an appetizer and a large cheese pizza to share. The pizza was really good. My friend really liked the wings. I think they could be better at telling people the wait times. But the food is good if you’re willing to wait.

Delicious pizza. Really, really good. Five stars.
Very generous wine pours and well priced.
The bad: being picky, I know, but we ordered a spinach salad and they didn’t trim the stems. Yuck.
I’ll be back for take out…

Pros– Excellent. Pizza is authentic NY/​NJ style. Great beer selection. Owner is super nice.
Cons– Small space so expect a long wait, we sat at the bar and the stools were really uncomfortable, a padded seat would have been much appreciated :(

Really enjoyed our visit! Only thing is it Seemed a little disorganized when we got there because it was so busy. If there are people waiting outside make sure you find the person working there that is taking names so you get on the list.
Took about 30mins to get a table. Once we sat the waitress was great and helped suggest some great beers (they will let you sample it)
Pizza was great — nice crispy crust — flavorful sauce

A wonderful local pizza restaurant with world class selection of craft beers. While open for less than 6 months the place is always busy with locals.
A great family place, as well as a wonderful place to grab a great beer and delicious food.
Highly recommend the place.

This place is really good. I just picked up my second order here tonight. We got a «Carnivore», and it was delicious. The margarita is not a true margarita here, but it’s also really good.
Update (9÷13÷2015): a single brownie was missing from my order, and when I called the manager actually drove to my house with the brownie! Crafty Crust, FTW! Btw, this time we ordered a pepperoni and mushroom. It is epic! Never a miss here.

We finally made it to TCC last Thursday. Knowing that it was a small place with long waits, we went early and arrived about 5:45pm. We took the last available table.
As others have mentioned, they need to work on the service side of the business. They were short-​handed when we arrived, which meant that it took about 10 minutes before we were able to flag somebody down and put in a drink order.
Another wait before putting in an order for a couple pizzas and garlic knots. We had drinks in our hands at this point though, so we were happy. The knots were really good! We really liked the dough that was used.
I had a gluten free pizza and my husband had the carnivore. Both were delicious and left lots for leftovers.
Overall, the food and drinks are worth the trip. The prices are right where they should be, so as long as you’ve got the patience while they work out the kinks, definitely check them out!

My wife and I really like this place but have had a few bad experiences there the last few times we visited. We wanted to try something other than their delicious Margarita pizza and tried the Philly cheese steak. It was such a disappointment — the steak was cubed and it just didn’t look or taste like a Philly cheese steak. We usually get pickup and wanted to eat in a few times for lunch… but when we walked in the entire place was packed. Being packed is great, but that wasn’t the problem. We walked in and no one greeted us. We walked back and tried to talk to the only person working, but she was too busy/​flustered to even seat us. After about 5 mins of waiting around, we just left. I hope they hire more help because we really like most of their food.

I’m a New Yorker, so I know pizza. And using my favorite pizza place as a gauge (Dani’s House of Pizza in Queens), I rate this place a 8 ½ out of 10. The pizza is great, nice selection of beer, and the people working here are as friendly as can be. As far as I’m concerned after moving to FL, this is my go to non-​chain Pizza Place.
Go in, buy pizza, eat pizza, leave, repeat.

Just had our first pizza here.
They have a good pie.
A very nice woman owns the place she is bubbling with enthusiasm.
She has hired a crew that is unusual now a days they are also filled with enthusiasm.
We are here for only three months but we will be back.
If you live here year round you should definitely give the place a taste.

Heard of this little spot from a regular at work. We were in the tequesta area, so decided to try it out. So glad we did! Great craft beer list, and reasonably priced! Grapefruit sculpin on draft for 5 $$$!!!
Pizza by the slice specials and includes a soda. Specialty pizzas, craft beers, and awesome service! Was a pleasure speaking with the owner, which is very hands on. Me and my wife are both in the business, so was very refreshing to see a small place with big potential, doing it the right way!
When in the area give them a try, won’t be disappointed.